Mimsofthedawg said:
The thing is that people perspectives and cultural experiences shapes their understanding of the world. Not only does this allow science to be a form of faith (something like 80% of people would do something simply because a guy in a lab coat says to do it), but they could be blind to solutions to problems, or they could make up evidence that doesn't exist (see BOTH evolution and Creation... both are full of indescrepencies, and neither person from either side of the debate is willing to give the other room to explain themselves. It's classic "faith wars").
At the same time, the faith that humans can overcome problems through irrational logic and reason (which is another root of science) has led us to some of the greatest discoveries, and will likely be what leads us to even greater.
I absolutely agree with the idea that science is a type of faith - or at least the way western culture worships it.
Sorry, but what a load of bollocks. Specially the part about creationism and evolution. If you haven't noticed, the only place where this dicussion is seriously debated is the US. In the rest of the world this isn't even a topic.
And both sides had at least a few hundred times to explain them self.
But when the creationists are saying the Earth is only 6'000 years old and one can bring up a few dozen things that prove their basic premises wrong, what else is there to talk about? This "thesis" got debunked over and over again. Also why try to prove X has created Y, when you can't even prove that X exists in the first place <.<
If i'd tell you my rocket powered flying Go-kart shoots flaming chimps, you'd probably not say "It definitly can't shoot flaming chimps", right?
Also about the "A scientist can claim anything and everyone believes it" part. Are you referring to complete idiots or to the majority of people?
You know that new findings get peer reviewed and tested by other scientists and professionals before it is accepted by the scientific community? There's not just 1 guy, who can shout out some dogmas and suddenly millions of people change their way of living. There has to be evidence, it has to be reproduce-able etc. etc.
Also even if a group claims X, contrary to believers, a secular person doesn't have to agree with them on X and nothing bad will happen to that person if he doesn't accept that.
Some other guys get told they burn for all eternity..
2 other points:
Can you explain me, which problems we can solve only through faith? It seems you imply, there's something we couldn't do by a secular way of living and since such a situation never occured to me, i'm intrigued to hear more about that.
And last but not least: What exactly does the western culture worship? Science? And how do we do that? Can't wrap my head around this.
Are we praising math? Or chemistry? Or do we thank our researchers everday that we got our flu shots? I don't get it.
Edit: @Syntax Error
Nope, faith is strongly connected to religion. Faith for me mean, i don't need a logical conclusion - everything can be irrational and i just have to take a "leap" in my mind and everything is still fine.
What you describe is "trust". I don't "believe" in my skills. I expirienced first hand what i can do, i can guess how hard/easy a certain task would be for me and then i can trust myself that i'm able to do it - or not.
For things i've evidence, a logical conclusion or just mere examination, i can trust - i don't need faith for that.