You know what's really great? The Cat and the Coup [http://store.steampowered.com/app/95700/?snr=1_4_4__13]. Not only it is well made, but it also bears a sensible message. Unlike this piece of turd. Can you mention this as well?
No doubt. I'd also like to nominate The Path [http://store.steampowered.com/app/27000/]. It's quiet to the point of ambiance but makes its point clearly and with little fuss. This Red Bull hipster mess screams so loudly to obscure the fact that it really doesn't have much to say. (Am I supposed to be impressed to learn that modern aesthetics suck? That ain't quite news, chief.)
I did not like that. I don't particularly agree with his "message", I didn't get the "art", and it was a pretty crappy game. I don't care how "artistic" it is, if there's nothing for me to do with it, I won't like it.
Like others have said, there's very little game involved with it, and since the message that I saw was relatively simple (not to mention old), then the game bored me.
I guess I'm in the minority. But I really loved this game. Sure it isnt much of a game, but it does borrow from much of contemporary art and I found myself playing it over and over, just to catch all the things missed. It seems like people either love or hate this guys work. If you go to his site: http://www.secrettechnology.com there are some really cool artworks. Check out Sydney's Siberia or I made this, you play this. we are enemies. So you can slam it if you want. But as art is subjective, I for one really like it.
This is my problem with the contemporary idea that "everything is art!" There is a practice of infusing your non-effort sculpture/painting/whatever with a thin layer of pseudo-philosophical meaning, that doesn't actually go anywhere, and then announcing it is a deep social statement and the interpretation is up to the viewer. Bollocks!
Layzor said:
For me, not art. Art is worthy of study. This seemed to be trying a bit too hard.
Yes, it seems to take all the modern art guidelines and run a marathon with them. "Oh look, my form and function is soooo random! nothing makes sense. Here's some random words, have you noticed how modern and unexpected our music is? BAM: quote about real estate. Oh look, the level changed halfway through! you weren't expecting me to do that! Aren't I arty?
This game is aesthetically ugly and haphazard, has no coherent narrative or plotline, no notable music or audio, no engaging gameplay elements, it's just a bunch of crap vomited onto a flash player and then paraded as being art because there is a vague connection to the economy running through the nonsense quotes and terrible visuals. That's not art, and it's not a good game either.
Aesthetically pleasing, a great contrast of the macho alpha male figurehead in the feminine realm. A genre-smashing masterpiece.
I have no idea what I won, or how I won. But I won. It told me so. I won! Or at least I survived. It told me I survived. But surviving is winning, right?
There's games as art (Cat and the Coup [free on steam, check it out]) and there's a mess being claimed for art. It's as simple as comparing the Mona Lisa to an unmade bed, one's obviously had a lot more work put into it and therefore merits more value. Like I said, one's art, the other's a mess. They can both have artistic value, but of varying quantities...
some forms of art go from 'i can sort of make out what i want to do' to 'alright it's the object i've tried to render' to 'wow that looks exactly like that object' to 'let's completely mess up what i was doing'
right out of the gate someone decided 'let's just make this as messed up as possible'.
Always disappointing when an "art game" only shallowly uses gameplay to explore its themes. It's a shame the SF MOMA chooses to showcase this over the work of Tale of Tales and Jason Rohrer.
Calibretto said:
SO all the people who wanted games to be ART?
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA @u
Welcome to the Art WORLD
There's a difference between something being considered an artistic medium and a medium being commandeered by modern art movements.
jacksonb said:
I guess I'm in the minority. But I really loved this game. Sure it isnt much of a game, but it does borrow from much of contemporary art and I found myself playing it over and over, just to catch all the things missed. It seems like people either love or hate this guys work. If you go to his site: http://www.secrettechnology.com there are some really cool artworks. Check out Sydney's Siberia or I made this, you play this. we are enemies. So you can slam it if you want. But as art is subjective, I for one really like it.
The other stuff is a little better, but overall the interaction has very little impact on the works as a whole. I admit that I could be missing something about Scrape Scraperteeth though, so feel free to explain more about why you found it so engaging.
So where exactly is the game?
After all the warnings I got into a messy application with no interactivity at all.
Zero interactivity and nothing of interest.
I cant believe after people campaigned for games to be considered an art form people are so blatantly trying to cash in with this drivel, with the caveat that if you dont like it you just dont understand it.
What a tosspot.
I know there's going to be an argument over whether this is art, so let me just say this. The argument on this sort of art ended a long ass time ago. Dada and surrealism are very much enjoyed by some of us. Check out most modern art, and tell me it's got more of a meaning than this.
He's very clearly talking about a certain theme, "More boxes for half lives! Let them build anywhere, anywhere." with a an aesthetic that, sure, some people dislike. I happen to enjoy it. I love his shit, and honestly this is the best one of his I've played.
The other stuff is a little better, but overall the interaction has very little impact on the works as a whole. I admit that I could be missing something about Scrape Scraperteeth though, so feel free to explain more about why you found it so engaging.
I enjoy the aesthetic he uses, and agree with the message he's getting across. As for the interaction, the fact that the interface is so broken is part of the aesthetic. It's not supposed to be a cohesive build. Feel free to respond to me as to why you don't like it- I've always been confused by the 90% of people in this case.
The other stuff is a little better, but overall the interaction has very little impact on the works as a whole. I admit that I could be missing something about Scrape Scraperteeth though, so feel free to explain more about why you found it so engaging.
I enjoy the aesthetic he uses, and agree with the message he's getting across. As for the interaction, the fact that the interface is so broken is part of the aesthetic. It's not supposed to be a cohesive build. Feel free to respond to me as to why you don't like it- I've always been confused by the 90% of people in this case.
Isn't the interface simply an extension of the aesthetic? Or were you referring to the controls? I didn't find them to be particularly broken.
Mechanically, here's what the work consisted of: a simple, linear platformer without death penalties and an emphasis on light exploration (to find the extra "flair" bits in each level). The only obstacles to the player are the heights of the buildings, which forces them to wait for the "elevators". Now, these elements certainly match Nelson's message, but that doesn't make them particularly revelatory or interesting. Indeed, if the work were a video of the man going through each level rather than an interactive game it wouldn't really lose all that much meaning. As such, I can't say that the interaction really does anything.
Contrast this with something like "Passage" by Jason Rohrer. A video playthough of that game would cause the work to lose nearly all its impact. The majority of the message of "Passage" is conveyed through mechanics alone, rather than simply having the gameplay mirror the aesthetics as in the case of Scrape Scraperteeth.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
