Sabazios said:
Susan Arendt said:
Waaghpowa said:
You forgot to mention it's a Suda 51 game! I personally love his stuff, mainly because he appears to have full creative control of his games, essentially doing what he wants. Killer 7 is still one of my favourite games of all time and I really want to get this one.
I didn't forget, I left that out on purpose, because while it means something to people who know his work, it's utterly irrelevant to those that don't.
That's like saying it's irrelevant to know if a film was done by Kubrick or not. The context is important for understanding what the game is, and explaining its idiosynchrasies, and if this is standard fare for these developers. If they don't know, then they should know. If this was a site for people who didn't care, it'd be IGN.
This site isn't
just for people who care about that sort of thing, it's for everyone, even people who have no idea who Suda51 is. If you happen to be well informed enough to know who he is and what that means with regard to game design, that's fantastic, and you're better educated than a lot of people who play videogames. But I don't write reviews only so that the hardcore audience will understand them - that's just plain not fair to folks who might want to expand their gaming horizons. I try very hard not to reference other games when I do reviews - stuff like "the inventory system is reminiscent of such and such" - because if you've never played such and such, that comment is utterly meaningless for you. I don't assume that the people reading my reviews come into them with a vast knowledge of gaming past what they do and do not enjoy, though a lot of people who hang out on The Escapist undoubtedly do know far more than that.
Given your example, for a lot of people it would be utterly irrelevant to tell them that Kubrick directed a movie, because they wouldn't be able to tell you any other movies he'd done, or even if they could, they may never have seen them. Saying "it's by Kubrick" is great shorthand, sure, but only helpful if you already know what that means. More people will be able to understand what you mean if you take the time to actually spell out the qualities of the film that "it's by Kubrick" conveys.
To say that "if they don't know, they should know" is forcing your personal values and priorities on other people. They can enjoy a great deal of really fun games without knowing a single thing about who makes them.