should have been free roam: Mirror's Edge and Bionic Commando

Recommended Videos

DrTrevelyan

New member
Aug 14, 2009
82
0
0
Oh boy I was really looking forward to playing Mirror's Edge. It looked so stylistic and cool. the aesthetics impressed the hell out of me, and I liked the concept of a game based around parkour moves. Then I played it, and it was as if someone clipped the wings off a baby eagle.
It really infuriated me that the game was so damned linear , but even more deleterious was the fact that it was an FPS. Why would you base a game around parkour moves, which are extremely graceful and fluid, and remove the ability to see them. Not to mention the fact that it made it impossibble to precisely jump and navigate certain areas beause I didn't know where Faith was relative to the level.
I know it's really elite to call all 3rd person free roam games "GTA Clones" but this is a game that could have been gold if they had made it a 3rd person sandbox game. I liked Prototype and Running around the City was immense fun for me, To have a game that would have taken that and fine tuned it would have been fantastic, frenetic fun. Sometimes a game NEEDS to be 3rd person sandbox.
Bionic Commando was another game that suffered , not because it wasn't 3rd person, but because it wasn't sandbox. If they had made the city a free roamer and allowed you to attach your hook to anything, It might have saved GRIN from suffering the agonized, undignified death it did. Is it not a natural thing to want to explore the world beyong the narrowed vision of some designer who is too attached to his project to leave you to find your own path.
 

Pimppeter2

New member
Dec 31, 2008
16,475
0
0
Too short. Doesn't make any real points. Tells us nothing about whats good about the game.

A decent review should be 800 words long. Use of pictures would be nice.

Lots of spelling errors, doesn't flow well, and some grammar mistakes.

Read some other reviews before you try again
 

SamtheDeathclaw

New member
Aug 8, 2009
1,091
0
0
A short wall of text? What a paradox. Well, I have verry little to add, but I do have something to say. Three key points I look for: Spelling, grammar, and points as to why the game is good/bad. You had a few points, but not many, horrible grammar, and bad spelling. Work on it a bit, and they'll be great. I would tell you adding pictures would help but I don'y myself...
 

jamesworkshop

New member
Sep 3, 2008
2,683
0
0
character said:
Im not sure I agree with you at all.

Firstly, Bionic Commando was doomed for the start and GRIN were never gonna be able to pull it off I dont think.

And Mirrors Edge use of 1st person gave your actions velocity and feeling, connecting you with your actions (especially with a beastly sub woofer)
I concur to be third person would rob it of any originality, 3rd person and free roam would have turned it into a tony hawks game minus the skateboard, FP gives it the immersion thats its you doing it not watching someone else