zauxz said:
If i break into your house, and build a copy of your TV, would i be stealing it? And what would you loose?
First off, you shouldn't be breaking into people's houses, as it makes you a major asshole and represents a gross invasion of privacy. Second of all, your analogy fails because in this case the problem is that intellectual property is being infringed upon, not any physical product. Games and similar are distributed on discs, but what you're getting is all computer code, and that code can be transmitted electronically just fine as well. Games piracy is taking the game and providing it for free, without permission. You can argue semantics all you want but in the end if people can get it for the low, low price of zero dollars, most aren't going to think beyond clicking "download". Not surprisingly, that usually means a lost sale.
It's not hard to figure out, and your rationalising does not make it anymore justifiable at a base level. Arguments like "piracy promotes future sales, strengthens communities, allows spreading of word of mouth opinions", etc. all don't matter if nobody's buying the software. What, do you seriously think that ten people per every one pirate are buying games, even though it's no secret that you can download them for free (there's that word again, it's important) and with almost no effort?