Skate. A Lesson in Architecture

Recommended Videos

tendo82

Uncanny Valley Cave Dweller
Nov 30, 2007
1,283
0
0
Much ballyhoo has been made about Skate.'s innovative control system. And while it certainly demands the most attention in the game's initial hours, it alone is not the reason I recommend this game. It is Skate.'s portrayal of the modern city and all its structures that should initially drive the player to the game. From there, in Skate.'s depiction of its San Velona, the game then achieves the profound - to convey to the player the aesthetic and philosophy underlying the act of actual skateboarding.

Until this point video game cities were fairly primitive representations, not far removed from their polygonal origins. They were a series of stacked squares and the occasional oddly placed half pipe. Subtle stylistic differences in architecture were not depicted, and environments rarely looked like part of a coherent whole. Typical environments resembled nothing so much as large skate parks that could be ridden as one continuous line. Developers were less interested in imitating a real city than designing it to serve a particular play experience.

Skate.'s San Velona is a remarkable departure from the previous design philosophy. The row houses all have walk ups, public art sits in front of the corporate buildings it was commissioned for, and half pipes can only be found in the city's myriad skate parks. More subtle, but equally impressive, is the empty space. There are open plazas with a few pieces of irregular terrain and a short handrail here and there. Space divides the city into disparate skate spots. In many cases, spots consist of one huge handrail or a single line. Some lines are obvious, but more often than not they resist immediate discovery. Like a real skater, the player has to look at the city in terms of gaps and grinds and, by doing so, finds a way to link the existing architecture to the physical act of skateboarding.

Once the line or spot is found the player finds himself sessioning it, often for an hour at a time, trying to lace the perfect line or even just a grind on the one enormous drop rail that might comprise the spot. The ability to replay the last 30 seconds of game time at any point and edit it in a fashion similar to an actual skate video adds a further aesthetic concern - players will become partial to certain types of architecture. If you are a stunt skater, you will look for large iconic architecture: that one massive ledge that you absolutely can't drop off of at the midway point. The more technical skater will gravitate to a city plaza with low, long hand rails, knee high planters, and 10 set stair cases. All of this is a wonder to behold under the city's permanent late Sunday afternoon sun. Even more remarkable is that deep into the game, when everything has been unlocked, the player will still be finding new spots to session, perhaps not as epic, but equally charming in their possibilities.

Ultimately it is not the control scheme that defines the game(that concept is quickly grasped) it is the extent to which the player can interpret San Velona's architecture as skate-able terrain that will determine the final experience. Certainly Skate. is not without its flaws, but none are so great that they should discourage a chance to roll around San Velona. To do so is to understand Skate.'s greatest triumph - its interpretation of the complex physical relationship between the skater and his environment. Fortunately this, unlike real skating, only requires participation to be understood.

Buy it.
 

Jordan Deam

New member
Jan 11, 2008
697
0
0
Nice read! I think you are correct. Skate makes a number of significant departures from the Tony Hawk series (the only real competition at this point) that I think will be looked at as pretty groundbreaking a few years from now. Certainly a solid foundation for a franchise (and if you ask me, a solid foundation for an MMO...but not in the traditional sense).

One small thing that bothered me about Skate: you are correct in that there isn't always a continuous line between discrete skating environs, but for some reason, the developers decided that you shouldn't be able to get off your board and walk! Stairs become insurmountable obstacles. I can pull off a double backflip rocket air, and yet when it comes to walking up a flight of stairs, I'm handicapped. Lame!
 

devilondemand

New member
Dec 14, 2007
110
0
0
This was an interesting read, good work. I just found that after about a week with this game I was bored. I'd learnt all the tricks and hit most of the achievements, and while I had by no means skated on every obstacle, there was just nothing left that screamed "PLAY ME" anymore
 

SecretLemur

New member
Dec 3, 2007
15
0
0
Wow. Having played the game, I could picture all of the elements you were describing. Very well done.
 

Swenglish

New member
Dec 21, 2007
272
0
0
That was spot on. Skate got a lot of credit for the new controls, but I reckon that some of that attention could have been focused on the city design. I loved that game, but after 7 hours of playing it, I found it impossible. It was unbelivably hard. Controlling-snapping frustrating hard. You just couldn't beat those skating superstars.
 

tendo82

Uncanny Valley Cave Dweller
Nov 30, 2007
1,283
0
0
I am curious what Black Box will do with the imminent sequel. It seems clear they will have to broaden the scope of the tricks. I'm sure they will redesign the city as well. This raises a few concerns for me. Namely, by including more tricks I imagine they will have to use more buttons, which might strain the intuitive feel the game currently has. Also I worry that in redesigning the city they will streamline it into something more artificial.

Just some conjecture, obviously there is no evidence on which these concerns can be founded.
 

strayjay

New member
Oct 10, 2007
52
0
0
Wow, probably the best piece of writing I've seen on these forums. Good work.

I think Ill take your advice.
 

FlamingSofa

New member
Jan 20, 2008
1
0
0
I agree with Ice-Nine, it's ridiculous how you can pull off such a stellar trick, but can't overcome such a simple obstacle. A good review for a good game.