Liquidprid3 said:
Why so so many people hate Duck Hunt Dog. I literally have not seen one legit reason.
For many, including myself, the issue is less "Duck Hunt Dog" and more the fact that his inclusion means that something else was looked over/removed to put him in. Generally, the idea is "But I wanted x character instead!" While this may sound petty, there's a lot that people want out of their characters, and DHD basically fulfills none of it.
We haven't seen a Duck Hunt game in a LONG time, and have no reason to expect one in the near future. The game is not a "core" game (people only know of it because it was an add-on on the original Super Mario Bros). The game does not need interest to boost sales or rebuild knowledge for a future game. DHD was never a playable character. DHD has no reason to be in a fighting game. The list goes on.
Remember the first big announcement of new Characters? Wii Fit Trainer, AC Villager, and Mega Man. You know who people ragged on? Wii Fit Trainer. Sure, she developed her fanbase quickly, but a lot of people did not like her inclusion. And, by the above metric, it's reasonable. How many of the above conditions does Trainer meet compared to ACV or Mega Man? WFT fits one of them, whereas Mega Man and even ACV fit most or all of them.
But people got over WFT quickly, because there were still 20+ characters to reveal. While the announcement here is so fresh it's hard to tell when we'll get over it, but I think it's gonna last, because we've reached the end of our line.
The hate isn't only for that dog, either. Paulentina, Baby Bowser and Rosalina are annoying. Dr Mario and Dark Pit not being reskins are freaking terrible choices. It's just that all of the hate for the roster is coming out in that one dog, simply because he's a great example of what the hell people are upset with on the roster. Same thing happened with ROB in Brawl, it should not be surprising that it's happening here too.