So.. i finally got around to "A Serbian Film"

Saladfork

New member
Jul 3, 2011
921
0
0
My problem with a serbian film is that when you put that many 'disturbing' scenes in a movie, they stop being disturbing. That one scene with the woman who was tied up, had her teeth pulled out with pliers and was forced into oral would have been quite shocking in any other movie, but in a serbian film, by the time you get to that point it almost seems normal for the setting they've created.

The scene where the protagonist kills a guy by

quite literally skull-fucking him

comes off as more funny than anything else. To me, anyway.
 

The Lyre

New member
Jul 2, 2008
791
0
0
WWmelb said:
I was completely with you until the last two sentences. I don't think it is odd to be shocked and appalled by the content of this film, and really think you are supposed to be.
By shocked and appalled, I meant more 'moral indignation to the point of demanding censorship'.

Obviously the scenes in the film can surprise the viewer, but thinking "How dare this exist, this is atrocious, how could anyone come up with this stuff?" is, in my opinion, a rather bizarre point of view.
 

The_Echo

New member
Mar 18, 2009
3,253
0
0
WWmelb said:
If you've seen it fellow Escapists, what are your thoughts on this film?

Unnecessary? Brilliant? Just average exploitation?
I like A Serbian Film. I really, really think it's a good movie.

It's very well-produced. The atmosphere is top-notch; the lighting and score, as well as the acting, are what makes this film. Without those elements, it'd be ranked with the Human Centipede as one of the scumbaggiest, laziest films of all time.

Yes, A Serbian Film will be hard to sit through. I did just fine, but then again I had been diving deep into the bowels of the Internet for years prior to watching it. But this movie needs to be brutal and disgusting; that's where its punch comes from. That's where the message it wants to convey is delivered. Like you said, it really couldn't have done the job it did otherwise.

I will watch A Serbian Film again. I'll probably show it to friends. I think it's a very good film, and it knows exactly what it's trying to be and what it's trying to do.
Saladfork said:
My problem with a serbian film is that when you put that many 'disturbing' scenes in a movie, they stop being disturbing.
Part of me thinks that might be the point. Eventually all that wretch starts to feel normal, when it very clearly is not.

I've read that the film is supposed to be allegorical to the then-current (maybe still-current) political and social climates of Serbia. I dunno how much weight that holds, though.
 

Cheesepower5

New member
Dec 21, 2009
1,142
0
0
I don't know, I've heard people call ASF a light-hearted family comedy...

I am glad I don't live in Serbia.

As I have no moral standard to hold anybody to, A Serbian Film is a movie that disgusts me personally, but I'd never condemn it. Hell, I've seen worse. It's just... Not my idea of a good Friday night popcorn flick.
 

WWmelb

New member
Sep 7, 2011
702
0
0
The Lyre said:
WWmelb said:
I was completely with you until the last two sentences. I don't think it is odd to be shocked and appalled by the content of this film, and really think you are supposed to be.
By shocked and appalled, I meant more 'moral indignation to the point of demanding censorship'.

Obviously the scenes in the film can surprise the viewer, but thinking "How dare this exist, this is atrocious, how could anyone come up with this stuff?" is, in my opinion, a rather bizarre point of view.
Ahh got ya. I misinterpreted what you said. So we are on the same page then. Sorry about that.

captcha: cabbage borsht. WTF is that? *quick google* Okay.. scarily, it seems to be a dish that originated in eastern europe... places like the ukraine.. and serbia. Fuck you captcha you freaky little spy.
 

Daraab Amin

New member
Oct 18, 2013
1
0
0
When you say 'film', it basically means a string of images on a magnetic reel that spins around on a spool preferably at 30 frames per second. During this, my stomach was churning at 30 vomits per second. I am a guy, not really sensitive but not a gore minded freak either. Means I am an average guy. Which is not what the protagonist is. A Serbian Film does portray the cheap, pathetic plight of the common man, ravaged by sexual desire and the desperation to achieve a satisfactory life (the wife's concern for money in the beginning) while all the government does is look down upon him as a scab, but just like any other shock movie director, it goes too far (I'm looking at you Takashi Miike). I do not think it was necessary to employ such extreme measures just to paint a picture of Serbia's condition. I do not think politicians rape infants. I do not think politicians pull teeth out with pliers. I do not think politicians put their penises in your socket. If such a despicable atmosphere defines Serbia, why not make a documentary? Ok, a documentary fails to make the emotional connection. What about powerful, punchy dialogue? I thought Transformers 3 and Crank2 had the worst script, wait till you watch this.
Of course, if one wants to imagine the extreme, there is virtually no limit. But there is that element of humane rationality, that A Serbian Film so conveniently ignores. It is here that I realized how disgusting, pointless and hollow the film was. It may appear to be very deep and a 'bitter truth' kinda thing but once you watch it, you will realize that the director has just operated on the principles of placebo, just to lure you in a gory, inhumane trap.
 

TeamDei

New member
Aug 4, 2013
17
0
0
The ending was great IMO.
It's like it was saying "Life is going to fuck you, even after death".

There were some pretty tough scenes to watch in this movie, but that's all it really brought to the table IMO.

As a movie, it wasn't that great.
As a shock tool/vomit inducer/morality crusher, it was a amazing.
 

KungFuJazzHands

New member
Mar 31, 2013
309
0
0
A Serbian Film is shock for shock's sake. It never felt cohesive -- it was a bare-bones plot with a bunch of insultingly hamfisted gore scenes, and I never felt an ounce of sympathy for the main character (unlike others here apparently).

I normally love these kinds of movies, but to me ASF just came off as taking itself way too seriously given the ridiculousness of the subject matter. If the director was trying to make a point about Serbian society, it got lost in all the overblown imagery of baby ***ing and misogyny.
 

lacktheknack

Je suis joined jewels.
Jan 19, 2009
19,316
0
0
It was too much.

It took any satire it was attempting and clubbed it to death with newborn porn.

You see, when Jonathan Swift decided to mock the do-nothing approach that Ireland was taking to British dependencies in "A Modest Proposal", he took ONE shocking concept and worked with it. A Serbian Film took ALL the shocking concepts (all of them) and did little with them other than say "So... this exists. Stare at it."

If there was a message about censorship in it, it was lost on me. It made me feel that there should be MORE effort into censoring snuff videos, if nothing else.
 

sextus the crazy

New member
Oct 15, 2011
2,348
0
0
Dr. Cakey said:
I have not seen the movie, and I doubt I ever will, but Oancitizen had a very insightful episode of Brows Held High on it.

Here's his review [http://blip.tv/brows-held-high/brows-held-high-a-serbian-film-5496005].
Quoted For truth. I was going to post this, but you already did. :)

OT: I haven't seen the movie myself, but if Oancitizen's analysis of it is correct, It could be pretty interesting.