Dark Souls by a mile. It's one of the best games this gen and probably(along with Demon's) the best action-RPG ever made as well as the best dark fantasy world ever created. The gameplay requires a cautious approach but is very deep and rewarding. If you're a fan of this genre its a no-brainer. The lore is also very intriguing but scattered throughout the game world for you to piece together. It's an acquired taste though that's why most people either love or hate the Souls games with very little in-between.
Max Payne 3 is a great third-person shooter with very satisfying gunplay. Also the cynical lamentations of its protagonist are tragically comical even if the story itself is somewhat lackluster. Great game but it's just shoot-out after shoot-out with little to no variety. They were really awesome but it started to drag after a while. So my only (minor) gripe with this game is that they should have added either more variety to the gameplay or made the game itself shorter.
Haven't played Saints 2. Saints 3 was great though.
Max Payne 3 is a great third-person shooter with very satisfying gunplay. Also the cynical lamentations of its protagonist are tragically comical even if the story itself is somewhat lackluster. Great game but it's just shoot-out after shoot-out with little to no variety. They were really awesome but it started to drag after a while. So my only (minor) gripe with this game is that they should have added either more variety to the gameplay or made the game itself shorter.
Haven't played Saints 2. Saints 3 was great though.