When it was first released, it made so much buzz that i decided to check it out. Hadn`t played/read any VN-s before, but since it was free and all, and everyone on the Escapist was saying good things about it, i tried it out. And well, i liked it. I don`t think it was mindbogglingly good, but it was interesting and well-made, and quite enjoyable. And not what i was expecting. So, yeah. It really surprised me, as well. I played through Emi-s route, and a bit of Lilly's, as well.
Also, i did play Dear Esther, too. I´m really not sure what to think of it. I don`t think i got the idea of it, I´m afraid. Still, it had some very beautiful sights to see, especially that whole underground cave and river system. Damn, those crystals and markings on the walls looked beautiful!