Starcraft DS: yay/nay?

Recommended Videos

wildcard9

New member
Aug 31, 2008
131
0
0
I'm currently playing both Advance Wars DoR and Starcraft when it hit me like a brick: why hasn't Blizzard, the company which made Evercrack look like baby aspirin and has won the hearts and minds of the people of South Korea, hasn't tried porting Starcraft to the DS, the console that practically prints money?

Then it hit me again like another brick: shoehorning an RTS onto two screens is about as easy as, to quote Yahtzee, "taking the crazy out of Richard Garriott". Heroes of Mana tried and holds a 65% ranking on Gamerankings. FFXII Revenat Wings did better (80%), but I digress. The big problem is too much going on on too small a screen; even then, with Revenant Wings, you have to neuter resource gathering and progressive unit construction among other RTS fundamentals.

But wait: there's Ages of Empires: Age of Kings for the DS with an 80% ranking and the Game of the Month award by EGM. How'd Ensemble do it? By making it turn based!

If Blizzard were to apply the Advance Wars DoR mechanics onto the best RTS ever made, it would singlehandedly sell like smack in South Korea alone. A few changes would be needed though. SVCs would build all the buildings instead of having to capture them in AW. Said buildings would have HP but, unlike in AW, could be destroyed by any method of unit. Research would be handled like building or capturing in AW in which you, say, select your academy, select Stim Pack, and repeat one more turn to complete. Hero units would be a combination of the AW CO mechanic and the Fire Emblem system: each has some sphere of influence, a special power, and you will lose if he/she dies. I don't think CO powers would work, thou'; they'd probably be switched out by allowing all 3 of the races (Terran, Zerg, Protross).

I hope Blizzard is reading this: This. Will. Sell. Combine one of your most beloved RTS games and the selling power of the DS and you will make obscenely large proffits. I am confident you will laugh all the way to the bank. Hell, I could probably guarantee a good 10000 who'd pay good money for the game.

Discuss.
 

Slycne

Tank Ninja
Feb 19, 2006
3,422
0
0
It almost happened, sort of. http://www.dsfanboy.com/2008/01/22/starlite-blinks-out/
 

LOOY

New member
Apr 14, 2008
132
0
0
Random argument man post=9.71523.727705 said:
wildcard9 post=9.71523.727471 said:
I Blizzard, the company which made Evercrack
I laughed right there.
Do you think he thinks blizzard made Everquest, or were you complimenting him.
 

MindBullets

New member
Apr 5, 2008
654
0
0
Turn-based Starcraft on DS? You've got my support!

Conversely, I'd also love to see an AW-based RTS on PC.
 

meatloaf231

Old Man Glenn
Feb 13, 2008
2,248
0
0
LOOY post=9.71523.727831 said:
Random argument man post=9.71523.727705 said:
wildcard9 post=9.71523.727471 said:
I Blizzard, the company which made Evercrack
I laughed right there.
Do you think he thinks blizzard made Everquest, or were you complimenting him.
wildcard9 post=9.71523.727471 said:
Blizzard, the company which made Evercrack make look like baby aspirin
He is saying that Blizzard made Everquest look much less addictive in comparison to World of Warcraft.

Just wanted to clear that up.
 

James Raynor

New member
Sep 3, 2008
683
0
0
I personally love Starcraft, but no; Starcraft is not a game for the DS, so it shouldn't be shoehorned into one.
 

poleboy

New member
May 19, 2008
1,026
0
0
I like the idea. But you're right that the DS screen is simply too small to properly play most RTS games. Although I've seen DS games that can tackle an impressive amount of units in real time, so maybe it's not impossible. I still say it is better suited for more peaceful strategy games though.
 

peterwolfe

New member
Aug 2, 2008
349
0
0
i'd like starcraft for DS, but mostly because my computer sucks too much to play real starcraft.
 

Woe Is You

New member
Jul 5, 2008
1,444
0
0
peterwolfe post=9.71523.728220 said:
i'd like starcraft for DS, but mostly because my computer sucks too much to play real starcraft.
What are you writing this on, then? A 486?
 

Mistah Kurtz

New member
Jul 6, 2008
435
0
0
Sure, why not? It seems like real time strategy could really be a strong point of the DS, what with the touch screen and all. Seems like it'd be the most efficient console for the job, excluding PC's of course.

And to the guy who can't play starcraft, what the heck? Did you buy your computer at the salvation army?
 

peterwolfe

New member
Aug 2, 2008
349
0
0
Woe Is You post=9.71523.728233 said:
peterwolfe post=9.71523.728220 said:
i'd like starcraft for DS, but mostly because my computer sucks too much to play real starcraft.
What are you writing this on, then? A 486? Starcraft is over 10 years old now.
it's not graphics or anything, it's just that my computer doesn't have any storage space, to the extent that whenever i try installing blank, it shuts itself down.
 

Woe Is You

New member
Jul 5, 2008
1,444
0
0
Khell_Sennet post=9.71523.727814 said:
I don't think the DS has the power to do a real-time strategy, it struggles enough with turn based at times. Even if it could, the screen is just too small. Nice idea, wouldn't work.
And this comment is equally befuzzling. I'm curious...what turn-based games does the DS struggle with? And if you can run Starcraft on a Pentium 90mhz (or even better, Warcraft on a 386), you can sure as hell run it on a DS. Hell, Slycne linked to a port of it that got shut down just after they had the basic game done. That thing was perfectly functional.

peterwolfe post=9.71523.728243 said:
Woe Is You post=9.71523.728233 said:
peterwolfe post=9.71523.728220 said:
i'd like starcraft for DS, but mostly because my computer sucks too much to play real starcraft.
What are you writing this on, then? A 486? Starcraft is over 10 years old now.
it's not graphics or anything, it's just that my computer doesn't have any storage space, to the extent that whenever i try installing blank, it shuts itself down.
What?

I have pendrives that can hold Starcraft more than 10 times over. They costed a whopping 9 euros a pop.
 

peterwolfe

New member
Aug 2, 2008
349
0
0
yeah, i have like ten of those, i use them to keep my itunes, pictures, other games, and anything else. in fact, basicly everything i have is stored on flash drives.
but w/e. i'm getting the piece 'o' crap looked over tomorow, after that, i'll empty some room.
 

LewsTherin

New member
Jun 22, 2008
2,443
0
0
The speakers on the DS couldn't comprehend the wrath of 5 simultaneous nuclear strikes and are therefore inferior and not to be trifled with in this endeavour.
 

wildcard9

New member
Aug 31, 2008
131
0
0
Random argument man post=9.71523.727705 said:
wildcard9 post=9.71523.727471 said:
I Blizzard, the company which made Evercrack
I laughed right there.
Fixed. I meant "Blizzard, the company which made Evercrack look like baby asprin"

For crying out loud, read the whole thing....

And I meant TURN-BASED Starcraft: not full-on RTS. I'm aware of the fact that you can't do an RTS right on the DS, so make it Advance Wars style.