Depends. I like steampunk influenced stuff, but when it's pure steampunk/cyberpunk I think cyberpunk tends to work better. Steampunk tends to feel quite superficial and unbelievable.
Steampunk vs Cyberpunk
- Thread starter WhyBotherToTry
- Start date
Steampunk - see Arcanum
the wistful dichotomy of new(relatively) and old, in a setting you dare not get your hands too close... marvelous!
the wistful dichotomy of new(relatively) and old, in a setting you dare not get your hands too close... marvelous!
I'll pick cyberpunk anytime. Reasons, well steampunk seems kinda farytaleish to me while cyberpunk settings usually have that "this could totally happen one day feel to it". Also I think it was in a ZP about Bioshock where the line "how boiled water can form alliances?" ran through and it sums up my thoughts about steampunk pretty well.
i think both genres are similar?
they take place in eras where industry threatens the natural or human element by suplanting it with the mechanical.
But i love the napoleonic era which influences much of steam punks costume design.Steampunk is less nuancedin its explorations of its overriding themes, its more blunt, obvious and dare is say kid friendly generally having a degree of humour about it.
But i prefer the cerebral nature of cyberpunk, it has more weight and is more likely to leave a lasting impresssion on me.
they take place in eras where industry threatens the natural or human element by suplanting it with the mechanical.
But i love the napoleonic era which influences much of steam punks costume design.Steampunk is less nuancedin its explorations of its overriding themes, its more blunt, obvious and dare is say kid friendly generally having a degree of humour about it.
But i prefer the cerebral nature of cyberpunk, it has more weight and is more likely to leave a lasting impresssion on me.
I prefer steam punk a lot more than cyber punk jus because I like the idea of steam punk fiction and the mechanic/victorian fashion.
I'm sure this has already been said here already but Steampunk and Cyberpunk aren't two completely different things, aside from the aesthetic and the materials used. Steampunk grew out of Cyberpunk as a parody - rather than being technofetishism from the future, it's technofetishism from the past.
I'm a Steampunk and, from a purely aesthetic standpoint, I'd say it's my favourite but I do like the idea of having a body full of electronics and being able to internet from my head. So I'm going to pick both. Unless your Steampunk is a Nerf Maverick painted brown with cogs stuck on in which case I am going to have to ask you to step outside.
I imagine Cyberpunk meets involve fewer trips to Railway museums but they also involve less cake.
I'm a Steampunk and, from a purely aesthetic standpoint, I'd say it's my favourite but I do like the idea of having a body full of electronics and being able to internet from my head. So I'm going to pick both. Unless your Steampunk is a Nerf Maverick painted brown with cogs stuck on in which case I am going to have to ask you to step outside.
I imagine Cyberpunk meets involve fewer trips to Railway museums but they also involve less cake.
Well, of course we've got those, but we haven't really seen a serious interest in cyberpunk as there has been in the past.Xaio30 said:
Also, if you want a cool steampunk game, check out Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura.
It's available on GoG.com, which means it's almost guaranteed to work with any modern Windows OS (I have to run it as an administrator, though). It's a cool game, and it's made by veterans of the first two Fallout games.
Aesthetically I love both but I think Steampunk just about has the edge.
As an actual genre, I've not really read any steampunk fiction or seen a lot of steampunkish films. But then I haven't seen massive amounts of cyberpunk stuff except Blade Runner and the Matrix, and I'm not even entirely sure how much those count. So I can't pick.
As an actual genre, I've not really read any steampunk fiction or seen a lot of steampunkish films. But then I haven't seen massive amounts of cyberpunk stuff except Blade Runner and the Matrix, and I'm not even entirely sure how much those count. So I can't pick.
Two COMPLETELY seperate periods and ideas of the future?
Steampunk, because honestly it's sexier.
Steampunk, because honestly it's sexier.
i see wat you did thar.Richardplex said:
OT: steampunk. it just looks cooler. gears n shit. it's MANLEH!
MANLEH!
n shit.
I have a slight bias towards Cyberpunk as The Matrix, Blade Runner and Escape From New York are some of my favourite films. Also, Cyberpunk tends to be a lot more realistic and within the realms of possibility, which adds to the unsettling and claustrophobic nature of most Cyberpunk tales.