Still Alive Was Better

[callmegreen]

Hai Guys I just finished portal 2 and heard the new johnathan coulton song........ and I'd Have to say... still alive is A MUCH better song..because when i heard there was going to be a new song i shat my pants in antipation and its just...... Meh.. Also LOL Storage Shack In Wheat field

 

[Qwurty2.0]

That all depends on the person.

I personally like them both and refuse to define either as better than the other.

 

[Rabid Toilet]

You hate it because you were expecting Still Alive. It'll grow on you.

 

[Radoh]

I feel that the song was a let down because in Portal you did not expect there to be a nice little song at the end, but people knew it would happen this time. I think that the second one was good enough though.

captcha: resent brave

 

[kasperbbs]

They both are different and i think that the song fits portal 2 perfectly, if i were glados i would want chell to gtfo too. I don`t know which one is 'better', but i just can`t get 'i want you gone' out of my head, it`s so catchy!

 

[Hiikuro]

You hate it because you were expecting Still Alive. It'll grow on you.

I wouldn't be surprised if this is the case, as I was somewhat disappointed the first time I listened to it, but the second time I kind of liked it.

Also, singing turrets == awesome.

 

[GodsAndFishes]

"Want you gone" isn't as good as "Still alive", but it is a grower, where as Still alive was an instant hit.

 

[RejjeN]

They both are different and i think that the song fits portal 2 perfectly, if i were glados i would want chell to gtfo too. I don`t know which one is 'better', but i just can`t get 'i want you gone' out of my head, it`s so catchy!

Agreed. Had to add it too my playlist, it's awesome I think I enjoy it more than Still Alive actually, though that could be because I've heard Still Alive so many times already... Who knows, they're both great!

 

[HT_Black]

"Want You Gone" isn't as catchy or melodious, but it makes up for that with the sheer poetry of its lyrics. I, personally, think it's a step up from SA.

 

[Popido]

Still Alive was just more memetastic and unexpected. = lolololol must do a parody of this!

Want You Gone had more feeling in it and was overall more "humane".

I find no reason to be dissapointed tbh. They even gave you an extra ending song for bonus.

 

[RejjeN]

Still Alive was just more memetastic and unexpected. = lolololol must do a parody of this!

Want You Gone had more feeling in it and was overall more "humane".

I find no reason to be dissapointed tbh. They even gave you an extra ending song for bonus.

Turret Orchestra ftw!

(also: SPAAAAAACE!)

 

[TheYellowCellPhone]

I hate Still Alive because people like you can not stop praising it.

I actually like Want You Gone, and if you don't, fine.

 

[ramboondiea]

i preferred want you gone, though it was catchier funnier and darker. dont get me wrong, still alive was good, but thats just because it was morbidly funny

 

[Ninonybox_v1legacy]

You hate it because you were expecting Still Alive. It'll grow on you.

yeah..I though the new song was alright...but after listening to it for a 2nd time it becomes another still alive.

 

[mireko]

'Want You Gone' grows on you, but I'll agree that it isn't as memorable as 'Still Alive'.

Of course, the opera is better than both of them.

And everything else.

Even space.

[sub]SPAAAACE![/sub]

 

[Corkydog]

I like the song "Want you gone" better, but I like Still Alive's lyrics more. So yeah, I don't care.