I'm not saying it isn't a crime, I'm saying that the current setup makes it difficult to actually prosecute anyone involved, except depressingly enough in some cases the kids that actually fight back and then own up to their actions.Kendarik said:People keep saying what "the school does". After the first physical assault its a crime unless the kids are so young that they can't be legally charged (not the case with a 17 year old).
This guy is ***17***. He's pretty much an adult, he should have had this in hand without mommy giving him a weapon.
Bullies get away with physical violence only when the victims are too submissive to deal with the problem. They need to learn to stand up for themselves. That doesn't necessarily mean using force, but it also doesn't mean crying on youtube or a forum, it means taking positive action.
As for the rest, I've heard that before too. What positive action? Throughout this entire thread, I have yet to see anyone suggest an alternative solution for this kid to attempt that has a reasonable chance of success. It seems to me like he found a solution that works, and had the presence of mind to use it in a manner that caused no one any physical harm. Punishing him for it, while STILL not offering to actually help with the serious problems he faces, is extremely hypocritical.
The police can do nothing, their hands are tied, calling them does not help. At least not for the simple bullying case, an actual escalation to rape would bring serious attention. But those cases don't have an incredibly high conviction rate either, and in the meantime, I'd rather make sure it doesn't happen to begin with.Kendarik said:As a girl, let me say no, I wouldn't have supported her. I would have supported her calling the police.
As a girl, in a self defense class, she would have learned hold breaks, escape techniques, the use of keys as deadly weapons, and more. She also would have gained the knowledge and confidence so that 6 guys in a schoolyard couldn't put her in that situation of fear - all without ever being touched.
In addition, I heartily applaud the concept of learning to defend yourself, but no self defense course you can reasonably expect a youth to master can train you to handle 6 opponents with a strength advantage, even if they're untrained. Generally, the best you can realistically hope for against such odds is to cause a few of them temporary pain before they pin you, or to create an opportunity to escape before they have a chance (which isn't bad, but a school bully would just try again in an area where you cannot run.)
If you go all out, you could kill one, which would scare the others off and guarantee that you will be left alone by them, but aside from the "minor" legal issues with that action, I thought we were talking about keeping the level of violence down.