So because the one source you checked disagrees with me, that makes me wrong? I have looked up both words, and my source disagrees with you. So I guess then that gives me the right to do this. They are related. COMPLETELY. YOU ARE WRONG.yeah_so_no said:What?! Dude, "******" does NOT come from the word "niggard"--the two are completely separate etymologically. "******" comes from the French "negre," which was itself from the Spanish "negro," "black." And was a slur from the get-go in French, since the word for "black" in French is "noir."Weapon_Master_Jedi said:So because things are not as they should be, we shouldn't try to make it so? We should ignore the way things ought to be done, just because of a bunch of stupid, ignorant people who took a word, turned it into a belittling racial epithet?yeah_so_no said:You can not wipe away and ignore hundreds of years of a terrible history because the ramifications upset your delicate sensibilities and ideas of fair. You can argue that is how things should be, but it is not, I'm afraid, how things are in reality, where "fair" and "simple takes" rarely, if ever, actually apply.
The fact of the matter is, if YOU had done your homework - ****** (and I will use that word because I mean nothing by it, and it is racist of anybody to assume that I'm demeaning any of my friends with a different skin tone than I have) derives from the word niggard. Which means someone who is cheap, or ungenerous. Now, a bunch of stupid people a few hundred years ago decided it was funny to apply this word to black people because it is similar in its pronunciation to the word 'negro,' which is Latin for the color black.
I have white friends who use the word ******, but they don't use it specifically for black people. They use it to demean those who are stupid or ignorant, regardless of their color or ethnic history. So go ahead and rant about how its connotation is demeaning toward Black people. It's your right as an American. I won't stop you. But I WILL say that you need to realize not everyone who uses it thinks about it the same way.
Maybe if we start to understand each other's points of view, we can work together to build a better world for every-- wait, this is sounding a lot like something Yahtzee once said.
"Niggard," on the other hand, is Middle English (originally "nyggard") and from the Scandinavian "nygg," meaning "stingy."
"******" and "niggard" have not been and are not in any way, shape, or form etymologically related to each other. AT ALL. YOU ARE WRONG, and it is in caps so you get it. Go look up both words in a dictionary and read the origins of the word.
There is a lot you need to learn about a lot more than you think.
Huh. Somehow I thought that would be satisfying. I guess talking to a self-righteous prick who doesn't have anything better to do than repeatedly disagree with common sense never leads to satisfying results. *shrugs* Oh well. I suppose the big reason I'm not satisfied is that I know that you won't get it. Neither of us is completely right or wrong. The words did derive from the same origins. You just don't check back far enough. 'S the funny thing about etymology. It's hard to look back too terribly far. So ultimately, we'll both end up thinking we're right and the other guy's wrong. It's one of the big things about humanity. We're arrogant.
So instead of continuing to argue this useless point, let's just agree that racism is stupid, and that those who believe in it aren't worth our time.