Quoth the Imperial City Arena announcer: This should be interesting!
I am looking forward to more. Please proceed, Mr(s). Storyteller.
I am looking forward to more. Please proceed, Mr(s). Storyteller.
Oh that wasn't mean. I know mean. And that was too apologetic to be mean. But I would appreciate if you'd elaborate on some of your points. I'm more interested with engaging with criticism than I am with praise.piscian said:Trying not to be too mean. Art style is generic, safe and easy. I could have easily copy and pasted it out of any number of other webcomics(I'll leave the manga comments alone) You should try to to put yourself more into your art, even if people don't like it.
I'm not sure if I was expecting hilarity, but I'm hoping in the future this will be less luke warm.
Sorry if I came off mean. best of luck.
If it will make you feel any better, there isn't really a joke, per se.Darzen said:read this 4 times...still can't find the joke
I'll drink to that.piscian said:From what you've shown you've got a nice range in talent. Manga doesn't bother me I grew up with things like Guyver and Ranma 1/2 which are both forebearers of current manga and at the same time unique in artistic style to this day. I completely agree with your assessment of where your chosen style for this comic lays and that's what disappointments me. I do not claim some higher order of judgment on you for picking this style, but I do fear that you may get lost in the mix if you stick with it. I feel like sticking with this is going put you in a box for readership. It's clean, it looks good, there's nothing innately wrong with it, but that keeps it from being striking.
You don't have to stop using "Manga face", but that shouldn't stop you from adding some of your own personality into the style.