Thing is though, what if their arrest quota is down? Just raid a kid's iPod and BAM! A bazillion dollars in fines. Easy way to hit targets if they're struggling.008Zulu said:I think it was Finland, that a few years ago, passed a law that said something like it was only illegal to copy something if the data protection system employed actually worked.
Given the number of people who use iTunes and or make backups of their games and movies for their personal use would have to number in the hundreds of thousands. Now while the Mafiaa cartels are drooling at the prospects of chiseling so much money out of people who can't afford it, you have to wonder; Would the Police rather be chasing murders or some kid who makes a copy of his cd for safekeeping. Police the world over have stated that copyright infringements are very low on their "to-do" lists.
I've got a question, and if I sound like a dick, it's not intentional.Andy Chalk said:The Needles: Goodbye, Mr. (Mod)Chips
Soon, if the Canadian government has its way, the simple act of backing up your games could make you a criminal.
Read Full Article
Obviously I'm not a member of the Escapist Staff, but I think piracy could be likened to a competitor taking the articles someone on the Staff writes and giving them no compensation for taking said hypothetical article.danpascooch said:I've got a question, and if I sound like a dick, it's not intentional.Andy Chalk said:The Needles: Goodbye, Mr. (Mod)Chips
Soon, if the Canadian government has its way, the simple act of backing up your games could make you a criminal.
Read Full Article
There are a good amount of people who don't think filesharing (or "piracy") is wrong, but all Escapist news posters and staff seem to. Are staff members told they have to take an official stance of "against all piracy", or is it just a big coincidence?
Actually, I'm not talking about whether I believe piracy is alright or whether it's wrong, I'm simply wondering if the Escapist staff all happen to be heavily against it coincidentally, or if they're told they have to be for PR purposes.RRilef said:Obviously I'm not a member of the Escapist Staff, but I think piracy could be likened to a competitor taking the articles someone on the Staff writes and giving them no compensation for taking said hypothetical article.danpascooch said:I've got a question, and if I sound like a dick, it's not intentional.Andy Chalk said:The Needles: Goodbye, Mr. (Mod)Chips
Soon, if the Canadian government has its way, the simple act of backing up your games could make you a criminal.
Read Full Article
There are a good amount of people who don't think filesharing (or "piracy") is wrong, but all Escapist news posters and staff seem to. Are staff members told they have to take an official stance of "against all piracy", or is it just a big coincidence?
I'm sure you've heard similar comparisons before, and mostly they've been involved in flame wars. Please, please don't anyone turn this into any sort of attack, it goes no where.
One could even say I'll pirate your "if I sound like a dick, it's not intentional" statement.
There's no policy that I've ever heard of. I think you'll find that Escapist writers are generally against piracy because we've actually put quite a bit of thought into the matter.danpascooch said:Actually, I'm not talking about whether I believe piracy is alright or whether it's wrong, I'm simply wondering if the Escapist staff all happen to be heavily against it coincidentally, or if they're told they have to be for PR purposes.
I dont think it's illegal as the steam software offers its own feature of backing up the games however unless it has been cracked it dont see any problems unlike other PC gamers like me who buy the physical products then back it up on our own local network via storage devicesDiligent said:If simply burning legally purchased music off itunes would be illegal, I'm curious to know how it would affect making and burning backups of your Steam games. Does anybody know?
I couldn't see it affecting something like that, but I'm just curious.
Ahh, yes, because there's nothing you could legally use an R4 for, such as turning your DS into a mini-tablet or media player.squid5580 said:I dunno. When you can walk down the street and see R4 chips in legit store windows with big signs "R4 chips sold here" we have a problem. This bill the way it is written now is not the solution. Though it is good to see them stepping up to do something.
No bill which ever criminalizes duplication of any kind, save that which directly causes harm, is acceptable. Just like no law prohibiting any form of speech save that which directly incites violence is acceptable. In both cases, the burden of proof is on the accuser.Andy Chalk said:There's no policy that I've ever heard of. I think you'll find that Escapist writers are generally against piracy because we've actually put quite a bit of thought into the matter.danpascooch said:Actually, I'm not talking about whether I believe piracy is alright or whether it's wrong, I'm simply wondering if the Escapist staff all happen to be heavily against it coincidentally, or if they're told they have to be for PR purposes.
But there's a difference between being against piracy and being for draconian, corporate-driven copyright laws. I want to see content creators paid for their work. I want to see large-scale infringers busted and punished. But I also want the rights of the individual consumer protected. This bill comes close to finding that happy middle ground, but not close enough.
If it would become illegal to burn copies of purchased music from iTunes, I see no reason that it would not also apply to every other digital distribution system.mad825 said:I dont think it's illegal as the steam software offers its own feature of backing up the games however unless it has been cracked it dont see any problems unlike other PC gamers like me who buy the physical products then back it up on our own local network via storage devicesDiligent said:If simply burning legally purchased music off itunes would be illegal, I'm curious to know how it would affect making and burning backups of your Steam games. Does anybody know?
I couldn't see it affecting something like that, but I'm just curious.
Burning a CD from iTunes shouldn't be a problem. Apple applied the iTunes plus program to pretty much the entire collection... which means they are DRM free. Burn away.JRCB said:Good read, and this is very bad. You're not even allowed to burn CDs from iTunes? What the hell is that button for, then? This is bloody stupid, and I hope it fails.