The Non-Existent Title

[koschei8]

So I just got off the thread about the guy who pretty much loves Tool and thinks they're the greatest thing ever. Well it's his personal opinion I just find it to be a bit short-sighted to claim a band as "Best Ever".

So I want to hear some of your favorite bands, because from your own perspectives you can have favorites, it's just impossible for them to be the best ever due to the immense amount of varying opinions in the world that fail to give backing evidence for the claim.

 

[Rhymenoceros]

One of y favourite bands is La Dispute.
They're...
Different.

Also what's with the title on this thread?

 

[Furious Styles]

My favorite band ever is either REM, The Pixies, The Replacements, The Rolling Stones or The Beatles.
REM have the most songs I love, The Pixies have one or two songs that I consider to be among the best ever and one of the best albums ever, The Replacements have possibly my favorite album, The Stones also have two or three of my favorite songs ever and The Beatles have the most albums I like/songs I love.

Also, I think there is a legitimate claim for the Beatles being the best band ever.

 

[koschei8]

One of y favourite bands is La Dispute.
They're...
Different.

Also what's with the title on this thread?

Yeah i know it's a rather poor title I was a bit rash in picking it. It's pretty much pointing out the fact that Best Ever is a phrase that doesn't exist, and I just chose to apply it to the example of music.

 

[TeeBs]

I find it an insult to music, Not because he said tool, but because he said any band is the best band ever.

Saying a band can be defined as "better" is like saying Music is defined and there for not an art.

 

[koschei8]

I find it an insult to music, Not because he said tool, but because he said any band is the best band ever.

Saying a band can be defined as "better" is like saying Music is defined and there for not an art.

Exactly right.