Chester Rabbit said:
Fable 2 - Walking through Wraith Marsh when all of a sudden you see a familiar land mark...
Seriously I was feeling pretty dead towards any emotional toying this game was trying to pull on me and then that happened and for once I actually felt something while playing that game. And it was the only time.
That also got to me really bad.
Unexpected sad moments that got to me were:
Mass Effect 2-
[spoiler/] When you discover David hooked up to all these tubes in Project Overlord [/spoiler]
Mass Effect 3-
[spoiler/] Mordin's, Tali's, and Thane's death... Anderson's was sad but I was expecting it at this point [/spoiler]
The Walking Dead-
[spoiler/] Carley's death, when Lilly just shot her in the head without even hesitating. I was just silent all day after that. [/spoiler]
Guild Wars 2... yes, there was a sad point in an MMO for me :/
[spoiler/] In the Durmund Priory quest line, when you have to protect Lion's Arch from the Dragons and Undead, Sieran, that jumpy little Sylvari who's acted as the character's companion for hours now, sacrifices herself so that the player can escape. That really got to me, especially for a MMORPG. [/spoiler]