The first person Ripper was incredibly awkward. You don't do that to people.
+This game sounds nothing like Sherlock, but it would be hard to do it well. Holmes doesn't like scrounging about from evidence and prefers to make ever accurate but absurd logical leaps from evidence the reader wasn't ever presented with, whilst Watson looks on.
Heck even the PoV is meant to be Watson not Holmes. I don't feel any game could do the detective justice and be a good game
+This game sounds nothing like Sherlock, but it would be hard to do it well. Holmes doesn't like scrounging about from evidence and prefers to make ever accurate but absurd logical leaps from evidence the reader wasn't ever presented with, whilst Watson looks on.
Heck even the PoV is meant to be Watson not Holmes. I don't feel any game could do the detective justice and be a good game