ravenshrike said:
It's pretty clear the timeline went
1) Guy thinks of monetizing mods, floats idea to Gaben.
2) Gaben says yes, but go through Beth and check with lawyers
3) Mod marketplace is established with standard minimal Valve oversight
4) Internet blows up
5) Gaben notices issue, attempts to calm masses on Reddit
6) Gaben actually looks at how everything works, notices all the inherent fuckups
7) Gaben cancels monetizing mods.
There's plenty of opportunity to make a joke out of that.
I don't think that's how it works for mostly a couple reasons. Gabe wasn't around when the thin was released, and how Valve is structured. If you want to start a project in Valve you don't need approval, a forum sent in, or anything. You just start it, and if you feel like it you can pitch it to a feel co-workers and have them 'roll their desk over'. It's more likely that after they finished it, they brought it to legal consulting to get the greenlight paper work, and then besethda went okai.
The system is quite nice, it help leads to quality games most of the time because everyone's that working on it WANTS to work on it, but due to the lack of hierarchical structure it takes a god awful amount of time.
That being said I'm expecting this not to be over with. Be cautious of Fallout 4 when it comes out. They might try it again, and if there isn't enough lash back it might become the norm.