Video Games Can't Be Blamed For Humanity's Problems

Recommended Videos

Gotham Soul

New member
Aug 12, 2008
809
0
0
Note: I'm unaware as to whether or not his is a repost. If this is, please let me know and I will edit accordingly.


A recent article on CNet came to my attention. I'm glad that there's one voice of common sense among the slowly decaying cesspool that is the media.

http://news.cnet.com/8301-13506_3-10005871-17.html

For those of you who dislike links, I have copy/pasted the article below.

-----------------------------
Video Games can't be blamed for humanity's problems
Written by Don Reisinger

Sorry, but I refuse to believe that video games can be the scapegoat for all of our problems. Call me a video game apologist or just another gamer hack, but it's true. Why should the video game industry be blamed for the problems all of humanity faces?

According to reports, Thailand has halted the sale of Grand Theft Auto 4 after a teenage boy confessed to robbing and murdering a taxi driver in an attempt to recreate a scene from the game.

"We are sending out requests today to outlets and shops to pull the games off their shelves and we will replace them with other games," Sakchai Chotikachinda, sales and marketing director of New Era Interactive Media, told Reuters.

Always one to jump on the bandwagon, Reuters found an anti-video game hack to tell us all that it's only going to get worse, but we also should watch out for those GTAIV-wannabes.

"This time-bomb has already exploded and the situation could get worse," Ladda Thangsupachai, director of the ministry's Cultural Surveillance Centre, told Reuters. "Today it is a cab driver, but tomorrow it could be a video game shop owner."

Millions of copies of GTAIV have been sold around the world and when one crazed kid decides he wants to rob and kill a taxi driver, we need to stop selling the title for fear of more disturbed people resorting to violence? That doesn't make sense.

Sorry, but I fail to understand how a video game showing pixelated violence is somehow worse than a movie showing even worse violence. I know, I know, "it's the participatory element you're forgetting." Uh, no.

The fact of the matter is this: more than 99 percent of individuals playing video games don't kill people, don't want to reenact what they see in a video game, and don't perform these kinds of acts. Sure, it may be difficult for the average anti-gamer to fully comprehend when they don't hear the other side of the story, but it's true: video games are not the root of all evil and they shouldn't be the scapegoat when people try to make them evil.

This is just another case of an obviously disturbed person acting out in a way that doesn't fall in line with the norm. So he blamed it on GTAIV. Are we now supposed to believe that the video game is telling kids to go out and kill taxi drivers?

A dog told the Son of Sam to kill people. Should we start killing off every dog we see for fear that dogs are sending us subliminal messages telling us to kill other people?

It doesn't make any sense.

It's easy to blame video games when we don't want to blame ourselves, but it needs to stop. This person obviously suffers from some unique problems that the vast majority of gamers simply don't. I played violent video games all my life. You don't see me running out and finding the nearest taxi driver to kill, do you?

Each and every individual is different and there's no telling what might set them off. Sometimes it's a cheating wife, other times it's a dog, and still other times it's a video game. Until we start eliminating every cheating wife and dog in the world, I don't think we should eliminate violent video games.

Instead, let's try for some common sense.
 

JBX06

New member
Aug 22, 2007
56
0
0
Well Every Decade Has Has A Scapegoat

Hippies,
Jews,
Video Games,
Drugs
 

Gotham Soul

New member
Aug 12, 2008
809
0
0
JBX06 post=9.68228.622101 said:
Well Every Decade Has Has A Scapegoat

Hippies,
Jews,
Video Games,
Drugs
Yes, sadly. Twenty years ago, it was movies. Thirty years ago, rock music. Previous century, century before that, books. Every new kind of media. "Books, novels, corrupting our youth!" "What's the problem today? Our youth don't read enough books."

Well, okay. Interesting full circle we've gone there.
 

Broken Blade

New member
Nov 29, 2007
348
0
0
Gotham Soul post=9.68228.622114 said:
Yes, sadly. Twenty years ago, it was movies. Thirty years ago, rock music. Previous century, century before that, books. Every new kind of media. "Books, novels, corrupting our youth!" "What's the problem today? Our youth don't read enough books."

Well, okay. Interesting full circle we've gone there.
Heeheehee? by that logic, twenty years from now the source of all of society's problems will be that kids aren't playing enough video games. I can't wait to see what causes some idiot to say that.
 

metagaia

Random small pink blob
Jul 23, 2008
145
0
0
Well a quick check of the search feature implies this article isn't a repost. (Though the subject matter certainly is).

Honestly, I can't understand the point of these pat-ourselves-on-the-back-and-sneer-at-the-other-camp-stories. This is a gaming website. It follows that any discussion on this issue is either going to this kind with 200 'I agree' replies. The opposite gets accused of trolling.

We don't need telling this kind of thing, the disbelievers and waverers do and they won't be reading this thread, not here.
 

milskidasith

New member
Jul 4, 2008
531
0
0
When video games start having real meaning and depth to their plot, I bet.

Seriously, if video games were to start having tons of them being released like bioshock, I'd want people playing them for their education. Just like I wouldn't want kids having, say, dirty books be part of the school cirriculum, I wouldn't put pure shooters with no real meaning into the "learning" category, but some video games DEFINATLY carry a message even now.
 

BallPtPenTheif

New member
Jun 11, 2008
1,468
0
0
how about we look at this issue from the other angle. let's say that videogames do contribute to the spread of violent tendancies.

now what?

if we concede this point then we could logically concede that other mediums are also methods of transmission for violent ideas. books, films, music, etc... for the sake of arguement lets say that this is a fact. do we now build up federally backed oversight on all ideas screening violent or agressive ideas from the available content?

i say no. ultimately, in order for your personal decisions to be respected you must respect the decisions of others. i know it's scarry for some of us to say, "Maybe i'm not that smart. Maybe everybody is as smart and capable of making decisions as I am." and open the flood gates. However, i do not hold humanity in contempt and trust that each of us has the right to discern these things for ourselves despite the consequences.
 

Aries_Split

New member
May 12, 2008
2,097
0
0
FUCKING YES! I was watching an Australian goverment meeting, and when somebody brought up the concept of Violent Video Games, they were all like disgusted.
 

S_K

New member
Nov 16, 2007
163
0
0
JBX06 post=9.68228.622101 said:
Well Every Decade Has Has A Scapegoat

Hippies,
Jews,
Video Games,
Drugs
Not Jews religion in general, corrected for truth XP
 

Jark212

Certified Deviant
Jul 17, 2008
4,455
0
0
If you think about it raligion has resulted in millions of more deaths then video games ever will... so lets start a petition to ban religion!!!
 

aRealGuitarHero707

New member
May 19, 2008
95
0
0
why don;t we all just sit back and wait until all of today's youth grow up to become the voters, taxpayers, and parents that they are going to be

our time will come just wait and see

EDIT: sorry i meant to specify the gaming youth of today, but you all probably knew that already
 

Protagonist

New member
Feb 23, 2008
28
0
0
If anything, games can make you less violent. After playing CoD 4 and MGS, the mere idea of any human launching a nuke scares me crapless.

Also, the violent crime rate has gone down when GTA came out. Does that mean that it causes violence? Doesn't sound like it. I think the reason for all this blaming is, a kid did something stupid because they're stupid, then when someone asks them why and they say "Uuuuhh. Grand Theft Auto made me do it!" Its a quick easy excuse.
 

Jumplion

New member
Mar 10, 2008
7,873
0
0
I have a question, how long did the other medias get this much attention?

You say movies for one decade, music in another, and comic books in another decade of controversy.

How long have video games been in the hot seat? To my knowledge almost 30 years (1980s to about 2010 infact, more like 40 years for the 1970s)

That's a little long to be "just another scapegoat"...oh god, HE WAS RIGHT@!!
 

Auron555

New member
Jun 15, 2008
348
0
0
Thank you! People (the media) need to realize that dicks will be dicks, forever and ever, and there's nothing you can do to stop them. Just try and shut them up, but they will figure out some way to piss someone off.