Walking Dead - Do you Replay Differently?

[IndomitableSam]

Spoiler warning for the thread, obviously.

NOTE: I haven't finished yet, so don't spoil too much, please.

So... I should finish chapter 3 of Walking Dead tonight and I'm not sure I made the right choices.

Spoiler

Would Kenny and Kat stay civil towards you if you didn't save Duck at the farm in the beginning? If you save Herschel's son, do you stay at the farm longer?

Is there any way to NOT get thrown in the meat locker in chapter 2? I mean, I had no qualms about killing that dick, but it wasn't something I wanted Clem to see.

Also... Will Lilly always shoot Carly, or can you avoid that? I really liked Carly.

... I think I'll probably start again as soon as I finish to find out some of the answers, but what about you? Have you started new playthroughs?

 

[veloper]

You'll probably end up disappointed.
Some spoken lines will change, but the outcomes will not. Your only real choice is Doug or Carly and the consequence of that choice only lasts for 2.5 chapters.

 

[IndomitableSam]

You'll probably end up disappointed.
Some spoken lines will change, but the outcomes will not. Your only real choice is Doug or Carly and the consequence of that choice only lasts for 2.5 chapters.

Well, boo. That sucks.

Still, I think I'll replay. Got nothing else until the 20th, anyway.

 

[KhaoticOne]

By the 20th (Torchlight 2 =]?).

But yeah theres not really much point in replaying so far at least. The whole character dynamic part doesn't present it self much. No matter what choices you seem to make, everything still steadily goes into pace. And no I'm not talking about different set-pieces or change in overall plot I'm talking about how characters feel about you. Even if you were a complete douche to somebody they still talk to you the same (virtually at least) as if you were completely supportive towards them.

It would be nice to have characters disposition towards you play more in the conversations and maybe even events (like you less = stubborn about your risky ideas/plans).

Currently this is only speaking for the 3 episodes out, this all could pan out to something significant I hope.

 

[IndomitableSam]

By the 20th (Torchlight 2 =]?).

But yeah theres not really much point in replaying so far at least. The whole character dynamic part doesn't present it self much. No matter what choices you seem to make, everything still steadily goes into pace. And no I'm not talking about different set-pieces or change in overall plot I'm talking about how characters feel about you. Even if you were a complete douche to somebody they still talk to you the same (virtually at least) as if you were completely supportive towards them.

It would be nice to have characters disposition towards you play more in the conversations and maybe even events (like you less = stubborn about your risky ideas/plans).

Currently this is only speaking for the 3 episodes out, this all could pan out to something significant I hope.

Of course Torchlight.

I hope it all leads to changes, too. It does kinda seem like characters will die no matter what (whether earlier or later by different means), but it would be neat if there are really different tangents at the end.

Sort of like... (bearing in mind I'm not done 3 yet)

Spoiler

You do go to the coast with Kenny and Kat (and Duck, depending on how long he lasts for), or you end up going elsewhere with other people.

... I've only just met the train hobo while getting it track-worthy, though, so we'll see what happens.

Maybe next time I will take Lilly with us, though, to see how/if she dies.