Waltz with Bashir

Recommended Videos

J-Man

New member
Nov 2, 2008
591
0
0
In short, this is my film of the year. It's consistently brilliant throughout in every way I can think of, and it definitely sits among my top 10 films. I'll deal with the technical side first:

fucking brilliant.

Moving on... Nah, I kid. The artwork is gorgeous, using my favourite technique of all time; using colour to represent emotions. The washed-out yellowness at the climax of the film suited it perfectly, and the frequent use of this brings beauty to what could have been an entirely bleak film. The animation is great, although it isn't rotoscoped the animators have still been able to show emotions on the faces of all the characters.

In fact, the film is solely based on characters, rather than events. The centre of the plot is a former Israeli soldier with amnesia, pushed into searching for his past through hallucinations of a certain massacre (Sabra and Shatila) he witnessed. He does this by talking to other people who were involved in the war, and thus allows the film-makers to explore different narratives and storyline while still relating it to the protagonist of the film.

It can be bleak in parts, depressing in others and uplifting in none, but that doesn't stop it from being emotionally affecting and moving. I think an 18 rating is too high, there's only 1 scene with sex, and the worst part is the real pictures of the massacre. I'm going off-track here, but surely images of an event that actually happened shouldn't be concealed from us. Sadly genocide happens, and we can't just pretend it doesn't for the childrens' sake.

Anyway, the film wraps up nicely by showing us the reality rather than the hallucination. It's a deep film, and I recommend you see it. Definitely worth a BAFTA, hell, even an Oscar.
 

D_987

New member
Jun 15, 2008
4,839
0
0
After reading this review I still have no idea about the film, who was in it, whats the story about, how was the acting/animation (is it a cartoon, your review don't explain)?

In short, it needs a lot more work and a lot more detail. The authorial voice is good though.
 

wewontdie11

New member
May 28, 2008
2,661
0
0
Erm, yea what exactly is this film? You delve all too quickly into telling us how awesome it is but give little idea what it's actually about. A more detailed plot summary would be a good addition and a bit more detail about maybe some performances or any gripes with the film.
 

J-Man

New member
Nov 2, 2008
591
0
0
Cheers for the feedback, this was certainly not one of my best reviews, perhaps due to me quickly tapping it out in less than 10 minutes. But then again, I shouldn't be making excuses.
 

Brokkr

New member
Nov 25, 2008
656
0
0
D_987 said:
After reading this review I still have no idea about the film, who was in it, whats the story about, how was the acting/animation (is it a cartoon, your review don't explain)?

In short, it needs a lot more work and a lot more detail. The authorial voice is good though.
I second this.