Major Tom said:
Though I think the biggest problem with Inquisitor was the fact they changed the scale. That meant all new terrain, all new mooks to fight. And at 54mm, the mooks are expensive and the terrain rather larger.....if they had built it around their existing 28mm range it may have done better.
A very questionable move, yes. Not jsut making it more expensive, but making the models no longer interchangable with everything else. Made converting stuff much more difficult, and you are left with one or two dozen models used by everyone.
Of course, otherwise, everyone would have take 3-4 models from their 40k army or necromunda gang, played on their standard terrain, and models wouldn't have sold.
As soon as the game came out, people were talking about converting to the old scale.