Warhammer & Warhammer 40,000

Recommended Videos

Cab00se206

New member
Jul 9, 2008
160
0
0
This may be on the verge of what this forum describes as gaming, but what the hell.

My basic question is this: Which is more nerdly, tabletop miniatures games like WH or excessive video games, and how did it get so? Also, to what degree does one have to slip into either before they are branded as some mutant Uber-Nerd?
 

meatloaf231

Old Man Glenn
Feb 13, 2008
2,248
0
0
Well on the tabletop vs. videogames debate, videogames are considered less nerdy mainly because they appeal to a wider demographic than tabletop games do.

On the Uber-Nerd thing, I think it happens when someone's miniatures take over 50% of their time, space and possessions.
 

Wargamer

New member
Apr 2, 2008
973
0
0
What's nerdy? Wearing a Football shirt, sitting on a sofa, and pretending you know more about Football than the people who do it professionally.

Tabletop wargaming is, like Roleplaying, still labelled with this bizarre stereotype of all its fanbase consisting of pale-skinned, skinny people / fat spotty people who've never seen a girl naked.

None of the people I game with are pale-skinned. Some are verging on fat, but being 40-odd does that to you. All of them, save those who are too young to have done so, have slept with at least one other person (I don't say "woman", because some of the gamers are straight-females). Most have a far healthier sex-life than anyone who follows a "cool" hobby, like getting pissed and yelling at the TV during a sporting event.

Frankly, ANYTHING is "nerdy" when taken to an extreme. It really makes me cringe when someone tries to make fun of me because I can tell you everything you never wanted to know about Doom, yet think it's perfectly normal to have memorised the results of every Manchester United game since the founding of the club. I would argue that video-gaming, however, is far more nerdy; tabletop wargames and RPGs are by their nature a social past-time, whereas videogames (particularly now, not so much in the past) are about sitting alone in your bedroom. Unless you own a Wii, you'll be playing alone - people on the internet don't count.
 

Ultrajoe

Omnichairman
Apr 24, 2008
4,719
0
0
Id say tabletop, not that i think the nerd stereotype is true, but Video games are much more mainstream.

DoW 2 may convince them to get their hands on the miniatures though.
 

BBLIZZARD

New member
Jun 19, 2008
359
0
0
umm...what? I think there are way too many Warhammer and WH40K threads right now. anyway I guess tabletop miniatures would be considered more nerdy merely because less people play them then videogames. Also theye're more intellectual than most videogames. I'm not sure why the more obscure something is, the more "nerdy" it is. And why things like videogames are exceptions.

If a guy plays about an hour of videogames a day to relax after work, he would'nt be considered a nerd. If a guy plays videogames alot, and plays the better ones, he's probably a nerd. But if a guy Plays or has Played Warhammer, Dungeons & Dragons, etc. even not that often, say about once every month, he is almost immediatly labeled a nerd.

Nerd pretty much I guess means someone who enjoys recreational activities that are different from the majority of peoples. Once the masses start to enjoy some of those things (videogames) it gradually becomes less nerdy.
 

Wargamer

New member
Apr 2, 2008
973
0
0
BBLIZZARD post=9.69028.647762 said:
umm...what? I think there are way too many Warhammer and
Nerd pretty much I guess means someone who enjoys recreational activities that are different from the majority of peoples. Once the masses start to enjoy some of those things (videogames) it gradually becomes less nerdy.
It doesn't become less nerdy, people become hypocrites. ;)
 

Fire Daemon

Quoth the Daemon
Dec 18, 2007
3,204
0
0
Hmmmm, it seems that the Warhammer influx has started again.

Since the increase popularity of the 360/PS3 with the collage community, The Wii with old ladies and WoW with everyone video gaming has become much less of a "nerdy" pass time so I suppose that makes it less nerdy than tabletop gaming.

If only we could get old ladies to start collecting, then we'll be cool.
 

Eyclonus

New member
Apr 12, 2008
672
0
0
I have given up on Warhammer, and to a lesser extent 40K.
HORDES Will prevail!!!
 

Wargamer

New member
Apr 2, 2008
973
0
0
On a (sort of) related note, how many Warhammer / 40K players have had the pleasure of standing around discussing Warhammer Online / Dark Omen / Dawn of War / etc. and some smart-arse proclaim that X game is a copy of Warcraft / Starcraft? Better yet, what excruciating torture is best used to kill these individuals?
 

GloatingSwine

New member
Nov 10, 2007
4,544
0
0
On the Uber-Nerd thing, I think it happens when someone's miniatures take over 50% of their time, space and possessions.
Minis will tend to do that, since building them and painting them is a significant part of the hobby. (Witness what happened when Rackham changed Confrontation from assemble and paint metals to pre-painted plastics. Instant bankruptcy protection. Unpopular new rules probably didn't help).