Both of them are wrong. Xavier is too idealistic to think humans and guys who can kill you with one optic laser blast if they?re so inclined can peacefully coexist (not to mention, despite his telepathy, he can never
truly understand other mutants? plight due to his privileged upbringing), and Magneto?s an outright terrorist (although, no doubt, a ?freedom fighter? to his henchmen) who does more to harm his cause than improve it and genuinely believes mutants are not only different than humans, but
genetically superior (hmm, who does that remind you of?). Humans will always hate those that are different, but mutants are no different.
History has shown that minorities can still hate other minorities; think of how many black Christians are homophobic, or even how there are certain divisions within the LGBT community based on gender and expression. If there?s ever an event in the
X-Men universe where Magneto succeeds in what will effectively be a
human Holocaust, the weaker mutants will just start hating the stronger mutants.
Additionally, I?m not sure Magneto really cares as much about his ?mutant brothers and sisters? as he claims, since he seems to adopt a ?if you?re not with us, you?re against us? mentality and has shown on multiple occasions a willingness to kill other mutants for the sake of his ?cause?. He?s driven by the anger of having been a victim of the Holocaust; he still hasn?t gotten over it, and is paranoid that it?ll happen again.
Nonetheless, Magneto?s still my favourite
X-Men character, because I can emphasise with his mindset despite its flaws (not that I think people dislike me because I?m ?better? than them; I don?t have such delusions and I don?t know for sure that a particular person dislikes me for whatever reason, since I?ve never cared to ask, but I?d be on Magneto?s side out of self-preservation more than anything else). Plus, his costume and powers are awesome.
Bluestorm83 said:
I mean, some footage of Storm stopping Hurricane Katrina would go pretty far to turn opinion.
Although it could be easily turned round to claim that, based on her powers, Storm
caused Hurricane Katrina in the first place. Like with terrorist incidents automatically being linked to Islamism now, any kind of catastrophe could be linked to an unidentified mutant letting their powers go loose.
So, while the Mutant Registration Act in the first
X-Men film does reek of the pink triangle used to identify gay men in Nazi concentration camps, it wasn't a
terrible way to curb the inevitable issue of some of the more dangerous mutants deciding to cause chaos and then just fly off, causing more murders and property damage than if it was just some ordinary nutter. But unfortunately, it wouldn?t help mutant discrimination either. Just because you?re more powerful than your fellow man doesn?t mean you should feel shit about it, if you had no control over it.