Saints Row, I guess?
Before I get dogpiled, I'm gonna go on record saying I LOVE Saints Row, played the tits off the first two and am eagerly awaiting #3. They're great games. I love the nearly unparalleled interactive diversity and turn-about minigames and 'campaign' story. Basically, I love that it's an open world you can actually INTERACT with, EVERYWHERE.
I kinda find the writing an obnoxious hard-off on par with Army of Two and I strongly dislike the aggressively stupid tough guy swagger by way of post 2000's hip hop music video format. That makes me feel weary, very fast. So the attempts at humor kinda fall flat.
By contrast, GTA San Andreas similar sandbox crime thuglife open world humor actually got me INTO poppin' bitches with hallow points for the snitches... so I think my grievence kinda comes down to writing, tone and delivery.
I would probably have my holy grail of gaming if I could get something that was as feature rich and raw fun game mechanics of SR in a more environment and dialogue rich game like GTA: SA or IV. I don't know if those could actually be wed to satisfaction without compromise, but doesn't that sound GREAT? Anyone with me on that one?