Samsung Galaxy Nexus.
Unadulterated Android experience
Super slick
Beautiful screen (when it came out, it was best in class), 1280x720 over 4.65"
Amazing physical design (like all the Nexus phones, for their day)
I've had about 6 months with it now, came over from a HTC Desire HD, and before that, a Sony Ericsson X10. Always had Android phones, as I've always been attracted to their customisability and amazing integration with Google's other online services, which I use a lot. I doubt I'd consider an iDevice, primarily for the screen. Sure, the whole "Retina" thing is nice (over 300ppi resolution, for those still ignorant), but that's done by the Galaxy Nexus at 320ppi AND at 4.65" rather than 3.5". When you get a bigger screen, you never ever go back; whenever I have to use an iDevice now, I have to squint to look at what I'm doing.
Going a bit off topic here. One of the biggest dividers I see in this thread post between iDevice users and Android (primarily) users is this issue of "simplicity". Some people have made comments about how they'd prefer an iDevice because the iTunes music player is "just better". Android users counter with certain apps found on Google Play that are, in their opinion, superior (and offer the reasons to back their opinion up). I guess this just highlights that some people aren't afraid to dig for what's best; others yet just want what's stock and aren't prepared to look elsewhere.