What makes a perfect game...

[Zhandarr]

List all your favourite attributes from you favourite games that you would think would make a perfect game.

-Uncharted 2's Script
-Assassins Creed 2's Climbing
-The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion's Free Roam
-God of War's Boss Battles
-Bioshock's Emotion
-Left 4 Dead 2's Claustrophobic Battles

Post yours :3

 

[thiosk]

Spore's Galaxy
Warhammer 40k

 

[Aura Guardian]

Brown and grey colors. HAHAHAHA
Originality is usually a winner to me

 

[DrunkWithPower]

-Borderlands idea
-Call Of Duty control scheme
-Rock Bands soundtrack

That all would make for one rocking FPS in my mind.

 

[Eliam_Dar]

Deus Ex - Story
Hevenly Sword - Emotion
Demon's souls - Bosses
Half Life 2 - Preety much everything, but story is what I like the most
Fatal Frame III - Setting
Total War games - magnitude

 

[Kollega]

If some genius would combine weaponry design of Ratchet & Clank with gun-generating code of Borderlands... that'd be one hell of a game.

***

Alternatively: customization and insanity of Saints Row 2 (cranked up to eleven) + tropical island and stunts of Just Cause 2 + airstrikes and destructibility of Mercenaries 2 (also up to eleven) + spy-fiction style of Team Fortress 2/Evil Genius + colour descision used by Mirror's Edge = single most fucking awesome sandbox crime game EVER. I already have basic concept laid out, just for fun.

 

[Cpt_Oblivious]

World of Warcraft - Addictiveness
Crysis - Graphics
Dragon Age - Characters
Oblivion - Customisation
Spore - Size
Brutal legend - Soundtrack
Psychonauts - Humour

 

[Beatrix]

Lost Odyssey's Music and Art Direction.
Disgaea 1-3's Quirkiness and Postgame longevity.
Sims character customization and user content potential.

And for it not to be tainted by EA or Activision.

 

[manythings]

I agree keeping EA away from it is incredibly important.

Edit: Scratch that, keeping corporate commitee thinking of any kind away from it is important.

 

[Sephychu]

-Super Robot Wars' Plot, Cast and plethora of Giant Robots,
-Rock Band Soundtrack,
-Team Fortress 2's bonkers ideas,
-Brutal Legend's concept

How awesome and somehow crap would that be?

 

[tomtom94]

Football Manager's addictiveness
Timesplitters's MapMaker
Lego Racers' character creator
Mario Kart's frantic gameplay
F1 06's depiction of race-car handling

I'm thinking a racing game with realistic handling which is preferably fast paced and allows you to create your own race cars and race tracks.

For those not in the know, Lego Racers did character and car creation as perfect as I've ever found it. Timesplitters' MapMaker meanwhile allowed you to make many different maps whilst being very accessible, and Football Manager is the most addictive game I've ever played.

 

[Kud]

Mario Galaxy 2 - Graphics
Pikmin 2 - Gameplay
Super Smash Bros Brawl - Music
The Legend of Zelda TP - Characters
The sims 3 - Customization
Resident Evil 5 - Bosses
Halo 3 - Multiplayer
The legend of Zelda OoT - Story

 

[DM master]

Dawn of war (orginial)
Total War games: Size
Choose your own music but the game will turn it down for cutscenes etc
Online multiplayer without glitchers and annoying 10 year olds (This is a long shot )

 

[coolredmk]

Okami-Art

Shadow of Collosus-Boss Battles

Harvest Moon-Marriage

Legend Of Zelda- Story

 

[Vianyte]

The World Ends with You Loads of fun extras after completing the game or completing the main storyline.
SSBB Soundtrack.
Modern Warfare 2/Perfect Dark Multiplayer.
Timesplitters 3/[Some mod] Mapmaker.
Fallout 3 Loads different types and versions of enemies, all are interesting with some challenging ones.
Fallout 3 Save anywhere and anytime you please.
Okami Art style.
Resident Evil 4/Okami Bosses.
Metroid Prime Atmosphere.
Legend of Zelda: Orcarina of Time/Majora's MaskPuzzles.
Fallout 3Longevity.
OkamiCharm and emotion.
Bioshock/Mass EffectStory and Storytelling.
TWEWY/Mass Effect/OkamiGreat characters.