Boxing is a competition sport that can be applied to real world situations but I find it limitedMrStab said:I'm thinking about starting Boxing soon and possibly doing Krav Maga next year and I was wondering what experience my fellow Escapists had to offer or any advice regarding these two or any other forms of martial art also general discussion thread regarding it.
Not meaning to sound like a dick, but you sound really, really, really pretentious._alexisneverlate_ said:I've done aikido for about 4-5 years. Its not the most efficient style of self defence, to be learnt quickly and simply, but for a trained person it gives nearly unlimited understanding of movement, balance, constant control, distribution of mass, "flow", "the moment of intention of attack" etc etc etc - feelings, that would make any other martial art experience a lot deeper.
It's rather about opening own feelings and following them - meditation in movement, rather than simple techniques of "killemall".
Sometimes one feels like a jedi, making another person completely unbalanced (falling, "flying" etc.) by a very slight and narly non-visible from the side complex movements of the centre of mass, and just slightly modifying persons own movement "blending with him" - even funnier to do that without using any kind of force, just own weight.
I'd recommend videos on youtube like "Aikido Motion Capture - Gravity Clouds"
.
Just putting it out there."For a martial art, though, something more simple, physical force oriented and practical would do, though.
Styding aikido is really an art, giving so much more than just "fighting techniques"... and it takes considerable time, so its obviously not for everybody."
Best two unarmed styles there are - the best fight is the one you're never involved in, the second best is the one you can run away from.EverythingIncredible said:Yep.
I know "Runningawayitsu" and "Kickemintheballsarate"
Actually all the special forces units in the EU must have Krav Maga training. Most police and swat forces around the world have Krav Maga training too, not to mention the best bodyguards in the world too.JacobShaftoe said:I hear this a lot, yet I've never seen anyone who is proficient in Krav Maga actually IN a real fight with anyone who'se halfway good at fighting. All the cute training vids I see seem to have the same feeling I got when I used to learn kung-fu: The moves look and feel fantastic so long as the training partener goes along with what you're doing. However, since I started Jiu-Jitsu, I've noticed that anything you do even slightly wrong gets picked up on and exploited, yet even doing something 100% right as hard as you can fails cuz the other guy is just better at the counter/bigger/stronger/lighter/faster etc. I've yet to come across any boxers who'd let you kick them in the nuts, or hardened jail-fighters for that matter, and those are the kinds of people you really want martial arts to defend yourself from: The ones who can actually really hurt you, and are practiced in not getting hurt.VladG said:No real training. Come to think of it I haven't even been in a fight since 2nd grade (and those fights were considered violent if slaps were thrown around). Basically my form of self defence is looking somewhat like a 250-pound half deranged hobo.
But I do have some knowledge of popular fighting stiles and favor Krav Maga. Here's why:
Krav Maga isn't what you'd actually call "martial arts". Martial arts are fairly ritualized (especially japanese/chinese ones) and focus on form, technique and are somewhat adapted for competitions, making them safer for both involved. Krav Maga on the other hand is all about survival. Generally, there are no rules in Krav Maga, as it is a defense fighting technique which is not regulated, but utilized to keep the user safe and incapacitate the opponent by any means necessary. There is nothing holy (half the moves I've seen involve a hard part of your body and your opponent's balls, usually in comedic and eye-watering combinations). It's also considered the easiest and most efficient form of self defence since anyone, regardless of age, sex, prior training or physical condition can learn it very fast. It relies on short, efficient movement (none of that fancy jumping around, just a plain old elbow to the face and knee to the groin, thank you very much) and details many ways to remove and defend yourself against many common weapon threats(knives, guns, blunt weapons, etc)
Boxing is probably the most useful background to have if you want to pick up Krav Maga since it emphasizes punches as basic strikes which are useful in almost any situation
As a form of self defence I really consider Krav Maga to be the best choice out there. Other martial arts have, of course, other things in their favor: discipline, physical training, philosophy, but for pure self defence, you can't beat Krav Maga.
Not that I'm against Krav Maga, but considering the only people the israeli army gets to practice it on prefer slings and AK47's to h2h combat, well, it makes me wonder is all...