FalloutJack said:
Being attacked by a giant squid that's staring at you with uncomprehending lidless eyes as it snaps you in half.
To explain: Other animals in life glare at you with some sort of recognition. They acknowledge you. Even the predator who's either wary of your presence or about to strike is looking angry or hungry at you. Even sharks look anxious, whales sort of impassive. A squid glares open wide like there's nobody home, and that is the most unnerving look for something that's about to kill you to have. And since they have the biggest eyeball in the world and being in their environment means that you are fucked makes it a terrifying situation from the inherent danger to the emotional shock that squid's just looking right through you as you die.
Yes! I've always been scared of giant squids. Especially since they actually fit the bill as a huge "sea monster." If someone ever catches one and puts it in an aquarium, there is no way I would want to get close to one. It also fits well with my fear of dark, large bodies of water. Their environment fits the description perfectly.
OT: Spiders, rotting corpse zombies, disturbing ghosts/demons, that kind of imagery would scare me in a game if done right.
I also have a real life fear of being blind, in a game or real life, not being able to see would be torturous. I don't think I need to explain a fear of cancer either, not sure how they could translate that into a game. The prospect of getting it scares me to death.