Ever play The Darkness? Well, there's a moment towards the beginning where you visit your girlfriend Jenny's new apartment, and after getting the setup for the next bit of plot out of the way you can sit down and watch Tv with her. As To Kill a Mockingbird plays in glorious black and white, Jenny fidgets around a bit on the couch, plays around with your hand, and after a bit, she kisses "you" (this whole bit is not a cutscene, you understand) in a genuinely touching emotional moment that is only slightly marred by the fact that you get an achievement for having it.
This was not my moment. My moment came a few seconds later when I realized that this cheap, ugly, short little comic book tie-in game made me care more about an NPC love interest than any Fable title I've ever played, or any other game I will ever play.