What Total War Should I Play First

Recommended Videos

CrazyGeneral

New member
May 18, 2010
30
0
0
I am a RTS noob and a friends got me a Total War pack from Steam with medieval II Rome with the expansion packs and Empire Total War and I don't know where to start, any advice?
 

Megalodon

New member
May 14, 2010
781
0
0
Just play whichever game's setting currently appeals most. they're all fantastic.
Rome's the easiest to absolutely break, Medieval is slower to get going and the religion system is a bit of a pain.
Empire is solid, but Napoleon is a better game, defineately worth picking up if you like the others.
 

Gethsemani_v1legacy

New member
Oct 1, 2009
2,551
0
0
Rome arguably has the best AI and the best mechanics. Medieval II is a close second though, so it all really breaks down to which time period you like the most.
 

Lullabye

New member
Oct 23, 2008
4,424
0
0
Shogun total war.
Why?
Because every other total war will seem like pure gold afterward:)
(honestly though, go with Rome first. Medieval 2 is for pusscakes.)
 

angel34

New member
Jan 16, 2009
174
0
0
Rome was my favourite, but it isn't exactly the easy way to start playing RTS games.
 

Jandau

Smug Platypus
Dec 19, 2008
5,030
0
0
Medieval 2 and Rome are best. Medieval 1 and Shogun are a bit dated. Empire is poorly made and the combat is boring. Napoleon is a mini-campaign for Empire and not really much good.
 

azncutthroat

New member
May 13, 2009
1,260
0
0
Lullabye said:
Shogun total war.
Why?
Because every other total war will seem like pure gold afterward:)
(honestly though, go with Rome first. Medieval 2 is for pusscakes.)
Lol, Shogun: Total War was my first (and so far only) Total War game and I thought it was decent. But damn, now I'm itching for a good nation-building RTS... when did Rome and Medieval 2 come out?
 

Lullabye

New member
Oct 23, 2008
4,424
0
0
azncutthroat said:
Lullabye said:
Shogun total war.
Why?
Because every other total war will seem like pure gold afterward:)
(honestly though, go with Rome first. Medieval 2 is for pusscakes.)
Lol, Shogun: Total War was my first (and so far only) Total War game and I thought it was decent. But damn, now I'm itching for a good nation-building RTS... when did Rome and Medieval 2 come out?
Rome came out roughly a decade or so ago. Medieval is only fairly recent.
 

Toriver

Lvl 20 Hedgehog Wizard
Jan 25, 2010
1,364
0
0
Megalodon said:
Just play whichever game's setting currently appeals most. they're all fantastic.
Rome's the easiest to absolutely break, Medieval is slower to get going and the religion system is a bit of a pain.
Empire is solid, but Napoleon is a better game, defineately worth picking up if you like the others.
The bold is an understatement. If you're playing as a Christian nation, piss off the Pope and just about every other nation in the game immediately targets you for destruction. And he's got a short fuse. The only way I found to gain any territory without incurring the Pope's wrath was to claim it on crusade. Good luck defending yourself. I'm a Catholic and it actually made me curse to the Pope's face.
 

Megalodon

New member
May 14, 2010
781
0
0
toriver said:
Megalodon said:
Just play whichever game's setting currently appeals most. they're all fantastic.
Rome's the easiest to absolutely break, Medieval is slower to get going and the religion system is a bit of a pain.
Empire is solid, but Napoleon is a better game, defineately worth picking up if you like the others.
The bold is an understatement. If you're playing as a Christian nation, piss off the Pope and just about every other nation in the game immediately targets you for destruction. And he's got a short fuse. The only way I found to gain any territory without incurring the Pope's wrath was to claim it on crusade. Good luck defending yourself. I'm a Catholic and it actually made me curse to the Pope's face.
The other way I found to amke progress was attacking with 2 armies, one full of artillery first to knock down the walls, then send a fighting army in through the breaches to take the town. By the time the Pope's cease hostility order came through the target settlment was already under my control.
 

Toriver

Lvl 20 Hedgehog Wizard
Jan 25, 2010
1,364
0
0
Megalodon said:
toriver said:
Megalodon said:
Just play whichever game's setting currently appeals most. they're all fantastic.
Rome's the easiest to absolutely break, Medieval is slower to get going and the religion system is a bit of a pain.
Empire is solid, but Napoleon is a better game, defineately worth picking up if you like the others.
The bold is an understatement. If you're playing as a Christian nation, piss off the Pope and just about every other nation in the game immediately targets you for destruction. And he's got a short fuse. The only way I found to gain any territory without incurring the Pope's wrath was to claim it on crusade. Good luck defending yourself. I'm a Catholic and it actually made me curse to the Pope's face.
The other way I found to amke progress was attacking with 2 armies, one full of artillery first to knock down the walls, then send a fighting army in through the breaches to take the town. By the time the Pope's cease hostility order came through the target settlment was already under my control.
Taking control of settlements wasn't the main issue, it was keeping them. I got excommunicated faster than you can say "anathema" every time I took a place, even if I had previously been loyal enough to put my own country's Pope on the throne. That's when the Pope's loyal nations made me their target and soon had me on the ropes.
 

Megalodon

New member
May 14, 2010
781
0
0
toriver said:
Megalodon said:
toriver said:
Megalodon said:
Just play whichever game's setting currently appeals most. they're all fantastic.
Rome's the easiest to absolutely break, Medieval is slower to get going and the religion system is a bit of a pain.
Empire is solid, but Napoleon is a better game, defineately worth picking up if you like the others.
The bold is an understatement. If you're playing as a Christian nation, piss off the Pope and just about every other nation in the game immediately targets you for destruction. And he's got a short fuse. The only way I found to gain any territory without incurring the Pope's wrath was to claim it on crusade. Good luck defending yourself. I'm a Catholic and it actually made me curse to the Pope's face.
The other way I found to amke progress was attacking with 2 armies, one full of artillery first to knock down the walls, then send a fighting army in through the breaches to take the town. By the time the Pope's cease hostility order came through the target settlment was already under my control.
Taking control of settlements wasn't the main issue, it was keeping them. I got excommunicated faster than you can say "anathema" every time I took a place, even if I had previously been loyal enough to put my own country's Pope on the throne. That's when the Pope's loyal nations made me their target and soon had me on the ropes.
That really does suck, I only ever got threatened with excommunication, except when I had the resources to immedialtely buy my way back into the Pope's good books so i could ignore the treats. Killing the Pope was also useful, not only does to bring excommunicate nation back into the fold, it really madkes you feel better.
 

Jandau

Smug Platypus
Dec 19, 2008
5,030
0
0
toriver said:
Megalodon said:
Just play whichever game's setting currently appeals most. they're all fantastic.
Rome's the easiest to absolutely break, Medieval is slower to get going and the religion system is a bit of a pain.
Empire is solid, but Napoleon is a better game, defineately worth picking up if you like the others.
The bold is an understatement. If you're playing as a Christian nation, piss off the Pope and just about every other nation in the game immediately targets you for destruction. And he's got a short fuse. The only way I found to gain any territory without incurring the Pope's wrath was to claim it on crusade. Good luck defending yourself. I'm a Catholic and it actually made me curse to the Pope's face.
Step 1. Get a diplomat to Rome.

Step 2. Give the Pope a gift of 100-200 gold per turn over a long period of time (say 20-30 turns). Throw in some map information as well.

Step 3. Watch your approval go all the way up in a few turns.

Step 4. Wait for other Christian nations to attack you. They will, eventually. Focus on conquering neutral provinces in the meantime and building up your economy.

Step 5. In a war, the Pope favours the side with more approval. Also, he favors the defender (that's why you waited to get attacked). If he tells you to stop fighting, do so and let the enemy attack you.

Step 5.1. If you have maxed approval, break the Pope's orders. You won't get excomunicated, you'll just lose a point or two on the approval scale, and your tribute will boost it right back up.

Step 6. Watch the other side get excomunicated for repeatedly attacking you (Pope's best friend).

Step 7. Conquer the excomunicated faction. Hell, you can even call a Crusade on them.

Seriously, the whole Pope mechanic is so easy to exploit that it's ridiculous! For extra fun with Musilim factions, do steps 1. & 2. and you'll never have to worry about a Crusade again - the Pope won't call one on you if he loves you.