Vault Girl said:
no matter how much we pretend it was to end a war, America is responsible for one of the most vial and inhuman acts ever created by man. The attacks on Hiroshima and Nagasaki cannot ever be forgiven, no matter how much scientific progress, nor "peace that followed" can be enough.
The Holocaust AND the Nuclear attacks on Japan are one of the most base and animalistic attacks on our own species to ever happen. Why does everyone separate the nuclear attacks as a necessary evil?
Please tell me you aren't equating the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki with the Holocaust...
For starters, in simple logistics the Holocaust killed
exponentially more people. Not only were they killed, they were tortured, starved, and beaten. They would hide for years, barely surviving, only to be caught and killed. It was a systematic annihilation over a period of years, and it was coldly calculated, planned, and executed.
The Atom bombing was done in the believe that it would end a war far less bloodily. The people responsible have been wracked with guilt ever since, and it was perpetuated by a small few who considered it carefully, losing sleep over it rather than thousands of individuals who enjoyed doing it. I'm not arguing whether it was worth it or not, but the estimates at the time believed millions of civilians and soldiers would be killed and Japan devastated during a ground war.
Look, Japan at the time was
absolutely fanatical. Civilians were being trained to use weapons against invading soldiers, and in street to street fighting infinitely more destruction would have occurred. It's possibly they may never have surrendered, and an insurgency could have been waged for using, killing many and absolutely destroying US/Japan relations.