Which Monkey Island game was the best?

[Jandau]

1-3 are all brilliant, for different reasons. 1 was the most original (being the first), the second one was a great iteration, expanding on the original's themes, and 3 modernized the visuals wonderfully and polished the concept. From there on, it went to shit.

 

[Guy from the 80's]

Secret of...and I prefer the originals. The voice overs and fancy graphics does nothing for me. Guybrush looks better with old graphics, same goes for everyone else. Then again I might be biased as its beloved childhood memories.