Who did it?

[NotAPie]

You all had to keep asking questions, You couldent just give up...
Im really a healthy orange...and I capped your donuts ***** ass.
Rawr.

 

[paladinkratos]

I know who ate your donut friend. My right toast on my avatar ate him and then he took revenge by eating him. Revenge is a very ugly cycle.

perhaps we should widen the investigation to what happened to AE86Gamer's avatars death as well. But this revenge theory might fit

 

[paladinkratos]

You all had to keep asking questions, You couldent just give up...
Im really a healthy orange...and I capped your donuts ***** ass.
Rawr.

is it because no donut has ever accepted orange flavoring is that what led to this? Or are you covering up for one of your friends?

 

[JMWahrer]

The butler did it!

But who is the butler?

me

 

[NotAPie]

You all had to keep asking questions, You couldent just give up...
Im really a healthy orange...and I capped your donuts ***** ass.
Rawr.

is it because no donut has ever accepted orange flavoring is that what led to this? Or are you covering up for one of your friends?

>_> Maybe...
Or maybe he was the one who turned my mom into...ORANGE JUICE :O :O :O?

 

[Mister_Sarcastic]

It stands to reason it was Colonel Mustard in the Library WITH A FORK D=

 

[Nia-san]

mmm jelly

 

[Nouw]

It was Homer Simpson case solved. Actaully it was Homer Simpson in the lounge with a fork.
LOL Cluedo.

 

[Aptspire]

There is another thread out there that's named "I did it!"
You might wanna investigate
(just kidding)

 

[Glerken]

The butler did it!

But who is the butler?

A piece of toast.

 

[Trivun]

The butter did it!

Bit of a cliche-twist there... It was the guy who works the bar. (Bit of an in-joke there, nobody here will get that since it's relating to a play I'm in). I reckon it was Max, and now he nees to get rid of the evidence. Speaking of which, I'm hungry...

 

[JMWahrer]

second guess cannibalism

 

[TerribleTerryTate]

The Donut ate itself.

Next mystery to be solved?

 

[JMWahrer]

no the other donut did it cannibalism that way

 

[I Stomp on Kittens]

I think everyone who has posted in this thread has taken a small bite..including...me

 

[Random Argument Man]

RANDOM ARGUMENT MAN THEME... (Which case will he solve today. Du dudduddududu).

Mmmmmmm... Based on the time of death...IT MUST BE SOMEONE ON THE FORUMS WHILE YOUR SUBSCRIBTION HERE. We have two major suspects. A. Thread OP B. The Escapist team.

Yes...Yes...The guilty iiissssssss!

ENDING THEME (JOIN US NEXT TIME FOR OUR MYSTERY'S CONCLUSION FOLKS!!!).


(In all seriousness, I think it's the Escapist team. They look like intellectuals that contributes to justice. However, I know their scheme. They're evil cannibals deep inside.)

 

[Datalord]

OK, i need a floor plan of the crime scene, all substances found there, a testimony of all suspects in the case, a gel electrophoresis machine, a gas chromatography machine, luminol, fingerprint search, hair search, and all miscellaneous peices of information involved in the case


$5 says it was Proffesor Plum, in the pantry, with the dentures

 

[Shadowlolz]

well since nobody finished the donut and it is strawberry frosting it wasnt me.. i will go with the old standby of the guy next to me I.E. poster above me

 

[UsefulPlayer 1]

The butler...

Nooooo!!!

How did they know!?!?!

*Runs for the hills*

 

[Avatar Roku]

what the hell is this? some kind of poorly written trolling mechanism?

No, I know the guy in real life, he's cool. I'm just having a hard time convincing him to use good grammar.