Who is the most powerful Superhero? - Can't seem to trump Silver Age Superman

rossatdi

New member
Aug 27, 2008
2,542
0
0
Mornelithe said:
So really, what you're saying is Superman = A weaker Goku? Heh, Goku's 'nearly died' several times, but come back rather quickly. Either way, as stated before, the power Goku exhibits, is on a level vastly higher than that which Superman exhibits. In that train of thought, Goku has the ability to literally beat him to death. To quote an awesome movie:

"If it bleeds, we can kill it."
I don't think anyone would argue that Superman (at least Silver Age, 1 million AD is another thing entirely) is stronger than Goku but I would argue Goku isn't really a traditional superhero. Its probably a cultural thing but he exists only to fight the next big thing - which often enough is only after him specifically to prove their the strongest. He doesn't even have a costume!

I'd probably rule out non-Westerner created characters just because they're so different.
 

The_ModeRazor

New member
Jul 29, 2009
2,837
0
0
I'm sure Hitman would find a simple way to kill superman...
Ok OT: Superman is just too cheap. He is practically invincible except for that one slight weakness, and yet all the bad guys just don't take advantage of that properly. They could just throw kryptonite at him, and even some random street thug would win that way, but NO, Superman's gotta win. As to the most powerful: either Juggernaut from X-Men, or Rogue from the same. Although I think it's rather Juggernaut, since Rogue can't touch him through his armor.
 

Christemo

New member
Jan 13, 2009
3,665
0
0
Dogwelder.

http://goodcomics.comicbookresources.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/09/Dogwelder%201.jpg
 

Reklore

New member
Aug 7, 2009
148
0
0
Batman. He ALWAYS wins. Dr Manhattan you say? Batman would build some kind of teleporter/power-blocker Bat-ray and tele him into a black hole or Bat-Black-hole
 

notsosavagemessiah

New member
Jul 23, 2009
635
0
0
Mornelithe said:
notsosavagemessiah said:
Mornelithe said:
TheGreenManalishi said:
Goku.

/thread
Agreed, Goku is the clear winner. Superman wishes.
The big problem with that, is that goku is an idiot. He wouldn't bother to think that to beat superman he would have to use kryptonite. He'd get confused as to why he couldn't just beat superman into oblivion, and would just keep trying to do so. Eventually he would tire, but superman would not, and after fighting at an incredible level for an extended period of time, goku's power would run out, and then he'd get his ass beat. Superman wins that too.
Actually no, it's already been proven via comics that Superman CAN be beaten to death. Literally. Death of Superman folks. Superman and Doomsday literally beat each other to death. It doesn't take kryptonite. Just someone really really strong and really really tough. IE. Goku.

Only issue with that is, doomsday is a kryptonian, hence why nobody else has really been able to beat superman to death. Look at darkseid he's thrown down with supes better then most anybody else in the DCU, can he kill him? no. The only people that can kill a kryptonian in just a plain old knock down drag out fight is another kryptonian. But then again, maybe the writers were just playing fast and loose with their own set forth rules in that arc because they needed people to buy their comics. I don't believe goku can win in a fight, simply because he doesn't have the right biology.
 

rossatdi

New member
Aug 27, 2008
2,542
0
0
Desert Tiger said:
Sentry could kill Superman.
Shit. That's a good one. My only counter is that 1) Sentry has fought the Hulk to standstill and 2) Superman has beaten Hulk.

Good one though, same he's an awful, awful character.
 

aaronmcc

New member
Oct 18, 2008
629
0
0
I gotta go for Bats. It was only a few years ago that Poison Ivy took over Supes mind and tried to have him kill Batman. Bats tricked Supes into Lex Luthors lead lined tunnels then beat his ass with the K-ring. Game over.
 

notsosavagemessiah

New member
Jul 23, 2009
635
0
0
rossatdi said:
No one knows said:
I don't know why, but I've never really liked Superman, most likely because he was so overpowered. However, Batman is awesome, not the most powerful of course, but he's the most awesome. Also, there was this (non-canon) time where Batman killed Superman.

Hush: Batman uses every trick in the book to not die for about 3 minutes.

All i can think of is batman thinking PRESS X TO NOT DIE.
 

GrandAm

New member
Aug 8, 2009
272
0
0
rossatdi said:
BrynThomas said:
Dr Manhattan, but only if he saw himself win in the future. Does he work with your rules?
Maybe but its kind of hard to scale him against other heroes as he's not fought super-powered foe. His time vision thing doesn't seem to be well used except for causing angst!
Your follow up may be unfair. Superman's primary supervillian was Lex Luthor. His super power is he has daddy issues and treats the women in his life like shit.

At least Dr. M did have Ozzy, fast enough to catch a bullet and military press a 220lb grown man through a plate glass window from 10 feet away.

Superman has a weakness (non-emotional), krytonite and the red suns rays. Dr. M has no physical weaknesses. He can reconstitute himself regardless of the damage. Even then if he only chooses to take that damage.

I go with Dr. M on this. Of all superheros I can think off he would kick all their ass in the end. Doesn't mean that other like Batman or Wolerine aren't badass or cool. But Dr. M has no physical weakness. All the others can be countermanded by him and his powers. Even supeman. He walked on the surface of the Sun.

In the movie Dr. M said he would see another galaxy. Superman came from another galaxy but needed a ship to do it. Dr.M can do it as a matter of will instantly (presumably based on the movie). If he can do it instanty it means the speed of light can be exceeded by him. Even the effects of gravity don't travel faster through space than the speed of light.

Superman did travel faster than the speed of light in the 1970's movie, but he does not reconstitute. If Dr. M teleported him to a Red Giant solar system, Superman would be screwed.
Not that Dr. M would have too, Superman is biological molecularly based. Normal man may not be able to affect it. But I believe Dr. M could. In the movie he could change matter. That requires nuclear energy (2M Kelvin) to add or subtract atomic mass. Superman still follows the rules of atomic mass and binding.

As far as his time seeing thing for angst. Agreed. But, short of a tachion field, nothing affects it. Even if it did, all his other powers seemed to work fine.

Yes I am a nerd!!!
 

rossatdi

New member
Aug 27, 2008
2,542
0
0
GrandAm said:
But I believe Dr. M could. In the movie he could change matter. That requires nuclear energy (2M Kelvin) to add or subtract atomic mass. Superman still follows the rules of atomic mass and binding.

As far as his time seeing thing for angst. Agreed. But, short of a tachion field, nothing affects it. Even if it did, all his other powers seemed to work fine.

Yes I am a nerd!!!
However, I wouldn't really call Dr M a superhero as he doesn't actually do anything heroic for almost all the book. He starts out as a hero then grows bored of it very quickly.
notsosavagemessiah said:
rossatdi said:
No one knows said:
I don't know why, but I've never really liked Superman, most likely because he was so overpowered. However, Batman is awesome, not the most powerful of course, but he's the most awesome. Also, there was this (non-canon) time where Batman killed Superman.

Hush: Batman uses every trick in the book to not die for about 3 minutes.

All i can think of is batman thinking PRESS X TO NOT DIE.
I lol'd.
 

Steve Dark

New member
Oct 23, 2008
468
0
0
Batman with... wait for it... PREPARATION TIME.

Ok ok, I'm gunna have to join the Dr. Manhattan bandwagon since his power was pretty much ascending to Godhood.
 

notsosavagemessiah

New member
Jul 23, 2009
635
0
0
rossatdi said:
GrandAm said:
But I believe Dr. M could. In the movie he could change matter. That requires nuclear energy (2M Kelvin) to add or subtract atomic mass. Superman still follows the rules of atomic mass and binding.

As far as his time seeing thing for angst. Agreed. But, short of a tachion field, nothing affects it. Even if it did, all his other powers seemed to work fine.

Yes I am a nerd!!!
However, I wouldn't really call Dr M a superhero as he doesn't actually do anything heroic for almost all the book. He starts out as a hero then grows bored of it very quickly.
notsosavagemessiah said:
rossatdi said:
No one knows said:
I don't know why, but I've never really liked Superman, most likely because he was so overpowered. However, Batman is awesome, not the most powerful of course, but he's the most awesome. Also, there was this (non-canon) time where Batman killed Superman.

Hush: Batman uses every trick in the book to not die for about 3 minutes.

All i can think of is batman thinking PRESS X TO NOT DIE.
I lol'd.
as did I when i thought of it.
 

SomeBritishDude

New member
Nov 1, 2007
5,081
0
0
notsosavagemessiah said:
The answer is green lantern. With that ring, he can do pretty much goddamned anything. Like make kryptonite to kill supes. But, as for who's the best, the answer to that is batman. Green lantern is the most powerful, batman is the the coolest.
Yeah, but Green Lanterns weakness is the colour yellow.
 

aaronmcc

New member
Oct 18, 2008
629
0
0
Didn't Batman shoot Darkseid and stop him from destroying the entire multiverse in Final Crisis? You can't really get more powerful than saving the entire of existence with a single bullet.