Eclectic Dreck said:
DoPo said:
While that quote is misattributed - yes. I am not sure why I am required to say it again, but the Steambox is a PC.
The use case of the device is it is used in the living room to play PC games. That defines a limited case of utility. A PC, on the other hand, is not explicitly designed to be used in the living room to play PC games - that is just one thing it is capable of doing.
It can, however, also do other stuff. As I said, we already have friggin gaming PCs which fit your definition of "limited" to a T - they are "designed to play games". Well, not in the living room but whatever - the limitation is there. Therefore, the gaming PC is not a PC is what you are saying,
despite being capable of doing other tasks. I can
again point towards the office PC though - the definition holds strong there: is it constrained to where you're using it? Yes, it's explicitly designed for the office, therefore - check. Is it limited in use? Yes - "office work" (depending in what kind of office you're in, I guess, but mostly an office packet plus something else) - check. Conclusion - office PCs are not PCs either.
Much like the Steam box, I might add, as you are not constrained to
only ever play games - go open up Open Office and write a poem. Or turn it into a file server. Or watch a movie. Or whatever - the facilities are there. It's not much more limited than many a different Linux distro.
Eclectic Dreck said:
DoPo said:
Therefore, made of PC components. I probably sound like a broken record by this point but it's only because you are relentlessly trying to claim it's not a PC by proving it is. It was a "dedicated" system exactly like gaming PCs, it is capable of being used as a PC and is made of what a PC is made and you made each of this claims. Only to immediately say "therefore, it's not a PC" every time after making those.
The OS is what makes it the dedicated system. The parts are entirely irrelevant in defining a PC. Literally
any universal Turing machine is capable of being a PC because it is capable of doing any sort of processing necessary to fill the "general computer use" case yet we choose to not apply that distinction to machines that are, by virtue of OS and use case, intended for some other end.
"But the semantics of the definition..."
A personal computer (PC) is a general-purpose computer, whose size, capabilities and original sale price makes it useful for individuals, and which is intended to be operated directly by an end-user with no intervening computer operator. This contrasted with the batch processing or time-sharing models which allowed larger, more expensive minicomputer and mainframe systems to be used by many people, usually at the same time. Large data processing systems require a full-time staff to operate efficiently.
Software applications for most personal computers include, but are not limited to, word processing, spreadsheets, databases, Web browsers and e-mail clients, digital media playback, games and myriad personal productivity and special-purpose software applications. Modern personal computers often have connections to the Internet, allowing access to the World Wide Web and a wide range of other resources. Personal computers may be connected to a local area network (LAN), either by a cable or a wireless connection. A personal computer may be a desktop computer or a laptop, tablet or a handheld PC.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_computer
A small, relatively inexpensive computer designed for an individual user. In price, personal computers range anywhere from a few hundred dollars to thousands of dollars. All are based on the microprocessor technology that enables manufacturers to put an entire CPU on one chip. Businesses use personal computers for word processing, accounting, desktop publishing, and for running spreadsheet and database management applications. At home, the most popular use for personal computers is for playing games.
http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/P/personal_computer.html
The letters 'PC' stand for 'personal computer' ? that is, a computer that can fit on a single desk for use by ordinary people, as opposed to a huge mainframe or supercomputer.
Although the acronym technically refers to any such computer, it has come to mean the multi-purpose machines that usually run the Microsoft Windows operating system, as opposed to the Macintosh machines made by Apple.
[...]
Windows is not the only OS that PCs can use. Linux is a free 'open source' system that has been created by volunteers around the globe. It's very popular among the technically minded, but is unlikely to suit a beginner. - See more at: http://digitalunite.com/guides/computer-basics/what-pc#sthash.Op3Pejup.dpuf
http://digitalunite.com/guides/computer-basics/what-pc
(I would semi-disagree with the author - Macs are also PCs, however, yes in popular usage, people do refer to "PC vs Mac")
Stands for "Personal computer." PCs are are what most of us use on a daily basis for work or personal use. A typical PC includes a system unit, monitor, keyboard, and mouse. Most PCs today also have a network or Internet connection, as well as ports for connecting peripheral devices, such as digital cameras, printers, scanners, speakers, external hard drives, and other components.
Personal computers allow us to write papers, create spreadsheets, track our finances, play games, and do many other things. If a PC is connected to the Internet, it can be used to browse the Web, check e-mail, communicate with friends via instant messaging programs, and download files. PCs have become such an integral part of our lives that it can be difficult to imagine life without them!
While PC stands for "personal computer," the term can be a bit ambiguous. This is because Macintosh computers are often contrasted with PCs, even though Macs are also technically PCs. However, Apple itself has used the term "PC" to refer to Windows-based machines, as opposed to its own computers, which are called "Macs." While the Mac/PC dilemma remains, PCs can always contrasted with other types of computers, such as mainframes and server computers, such as Web servers and network file servers. In other words, if you use a computer at home or at work, you can safely call it a PC.
http://www.techterms.com/definition/pc
In its more general usage, a personal computer (PC) is a microcomputer designed for use by one person at a time. Prior to the PC, computers were designed for (and only affordable by) companies who attached terminals for multiple users to a single large computer whose resources were shared among all users. The advent of the era of the personal computer was acknowledged by Time magazine in 1982, when they broke with tradition by choosing the PC as their "Man of the Year." By the late 1980s, technology advances made it feasible to build a small computer that an individual could own and use.
The term "PC" has been traditionally used to describe an "IBM-compatible" personal computer in contradistinction to an Apple Macintosh computer. The distinction is both technical and cultural and harkens back to the early years of personal computers, when IBM and Apple were the two major competitors. Originally, the "IBM-compatible" PC was one with an Intel microprocessor architecture and an operating system such as DOS or Windows that written to use that microprocessor. The Apple Macintosh uses a Motorola microprocessor architecture and a proprietary operating system. The "IBM-compatible" PC was associated with business and use, while the "Mac," known for its more intuitive user interface, was associated with graphic design and desktop publishing. Although the distinctions have become less clear-cut in recent years, people often still categorize a personal computer as either a PC or a Mac.
http://whatis.techtarget.com/definition/personal-computer-PC
Alternatively referred to as a Desktop and single-user computer, PC is short for Personal Computer and is a term coined by Ed Roberts when he introduced the MITS Altair 8800. PC is often used in the computer industry to describe an IBM or IBM-compatible computer even though the term PC can refer to any personal computer including an Apple Macintosh computer. In the picture to the right, is the Dell Precision 390 computer courtesy of Dell Inc. and an example of a Desktop PC.
http://www.computerhope.com/jargon/p/pc.htm
Eclectic Dreck said:
DoPo said:
You are pretty much failing the duck test here - "It looks like a duck, but it's not a duck. It swims like a duck, but it's not a duck. And quacks like a duck, but it'd not a duck. Then it probably is a duck but it's not a duck."
The better example is this: the PS3 was, at one point,
capable of being a PC. You could install your own OS and use it as a desktop if you desired. Then the ability to use that other OS was removed leaving you with just the ps3 OS. The hardware didn't change - just the OS and yet it became firmly "not a PC" as a result.
The simplest explanation, however, is this: You advocate taking a PC and putting in an OS that is less capable for most tasks (including gaming), a move that
reduces functionality, and then continuing to call it a PC. That's not a duck - that's a platypus.
I...don't even know what to say. Really - I see nothing I can say here except that you seem like you've only seen diagrams or pictures of Linux. That quote there wouldn't make sense otherwise.