Kopikatsu said:
Besides, there isn't any GOOD reason for it to be legalized. Crime goes down? Well fuck, just make murder legal and crime practically vanishes.
Normally I wouldn't, because these drug arguments are always so boring, but this made me laugh so much that I had to respond. Now, I have not read the whole thread, so it's possible I may be repeating what someone else already said. If so, I do apologize.
Anyway, that's a silly argument. The single dominant effect of legalizing murder would probably to cause a spike in murder rates. Social order would break down, etc.
The single dominant effect of legalizing marijuana would be to keep a lot of people who may have otherwise committed no crime out of jail. Or students who have otherwise done no wrong from being stripped of financial aid, keeping them from higher education. It would also eliminate the occurrence of individuals with criminal records for possession of marijuana from being denied employment. You can probably see why that particular analogy fails: Social breakdown versus freedom for people who have committed harmless "crimes."
Moving on, medical costs would certainly rise if use was legalized, however these could potentially be offset by the savings gained by no longer housing inmates that have probably not hurt anything significantly, besides their own lungs. More than that, there is the double gain that these individuals would no longer be trapped in jail, producing
nothing, but would be out in the wider economy. Counter to stereotypes of people who smoke marijuana, most do indeed have jobs. Anyway, myself I would prefer to spend more money on healthcare than on a bloated prison system. Gains in revenue from taxation would compound the cost-offset--revenue increases would not save any economies, but could very well pay the social costs of increased medical expenditure and then some.
The primary new costs would come from regulation of this newly-legalized crop, but I somehow doubt that it would cost more than the highly ineffective marijuana campaign of the War on Drugs. It might, however.
So, a benefit for the potential legalization of marijuana is that it would increase the autonomy and freedom for many individuals whose only crime was to use or possess marijuana, while probably offsetting negative economic effects and possibly resulting in net gains. Therefore, there are
good reasons for it to be legalized.