shrekfan246 said:
Loonyyy said:
So instead I'll say hey,
what a wonderful kind of day as far as licensed titles go there have been much worse than the
LotR games. Admittedly that doesn't lessen them not really "getting" their source material (and far too many spin-offs have spent too much time worrying about the Fellowship or creating an "original" group that was just a facsimile of the Fellowship) but they've been pretty decent for what they are.
Sure. The first game I saved money for was the Fellowship adaptation (Which was more booklike), and I played the Two Towers and Return of the King Games respectively, where they reached a more consistent theme and gameplay, based more on movie tie-in. And they were fun, hacking and slashing at Uruks, or sneaking around as Sam. The Lord of the Rings is a bit easier to adapt because there's a whole lot of violence in there, and you can draw that out, and that fits easily into established genre cliches. It's basically the videogame version of the other thing my brothers and I did as a child after watching the Lord of The Rigs or Star Wars: beating each other with sticks and making recklessly dangerous bows out of PVC pipe and builders string.
But they don't really carry the meaning, or the emotional weight of the story, so much as the visceral thrill of hitting things, something videogames have been doing for ages. It's hitting things until they stop moving with a Lord of The Rings skin. I'm not sure how you could do that with something like Twilight, since I don't think most of the viewers are watching it to see werewolves ripping people's heads off, that's mostly background to a romance that would be hard to systemise. Even if you wanted to make a Twilight brawler, you'd have to wait until the 3rd or 4th sequel to actually have content to base it on.
If someone wanted to make a Twilight game of any sort, they'd almost definitely have to make a game that has a less conventional playstyle, just to adapt it without having to write in a bunch of extra stuff to justify the gameplay. They'd have to make something like "The Walking Dead" (Which didn't exist at the time, and the predecessors didn't have the same praise), or "Gone Home", or a text adventure, but then it'd be really hard to make a simple tie-in. It'd be a really tough sell, and even worse if you couldn't focus test for women.