Whether it was illegal or legal isn't much of a difference IMO. When your livelihood depends on insider knowledge and contacts, there's always going to be back-stratching going on even if money technically doesn't change hands (and is then technically illegal). To think that any site/Youtuber getting early access is completely 100% unadulterated opinion (conscious or even unconscious) is a fallacy on your or anyone's end. I watch the official dev previews and can tell from that alone on whether game is something I wanna play or not. I'll be able to tell watching any full mission say from Red Dead 2 if Rockstar's missions are still super linear thereby defeating the purpose of their open worlds or if the controls still suck regardless of how much the developer or Youtuber is over-hyping the shit out it. You're not going in blind and the gameplay you see is ACTUAL and not fake. I remember back in the magazine days, the most you got to determine if a game was good were pages of screenshots. Now publishers show hours of unedited gameplay that you can find if the game is for you rather easily. If let the obvious marketing get you hyped for a game like how the aforementioned Red Dead 2 is getting hyped from GAMERS THEMSELVES, that's on you.altnameJag said:What WB did was literally illegally manipulative. You might be okay with that, but I'm not.Phoenixmgs said:Shadow of Mordor didn't try faking any gameplay. What you saw from the publisher or a "massaged" Youtuber was completely legit gameplay that you could very much perform in the final product. Just like the marketing of any product, you're going to see the product at its best whether it's a game or a McDonald's Big Mac.
And I don't have my self-imposed "no launch day reviews=no sale" policy because I have a problem with marketing. Marketing is fine as long as it isn't lying. What WB did was illegal by even the incredibly lax standards of the FTC.
I have it because it's anti-consumer garbage. Shill for publishers if you want, the facts on the ground are that most sales happen early, and having customers go in blind with only hand picked influencers showing guided gameplay is deliberate misinformation.
![]()