Then the oldest profession would be hunter. Lawyered.Redlin5 said:I think leadership is the oldest profession. The biggest, smartest, toughest hunter takes over a tribe. Now he has a job in leading that tribe.
oh, thats because my browser spellchecks in my native language instead of english for some reason or anotherDesert Punk said:More importantly what the hell is wrong with your spell checker?
And what was the payment of such pre-historian prostitute?Stasisesque said:Profession means something you are paid for, hence prostitution being the world's oldest. In that regard, I don't doubt it. It's been observed in the animal kingdom that primates will trade sexual favours for food, shelter or protection. It's obvious in our society that that still happens, so I'd say it's at least possible both we and our primate cousins learned it from our ancestors.
I can't agree that hunter-gatherer was the oldest profession, as they typically hunter-gathered for themselves or their tribe, they weren't being paid to go out and get food. Food was the payment.
Unless in fact it's not the prostitute who's getting paid but instead the gatherer, with monkey booty.Desert Punk said:For it to be a profession you have to be paid to do it though, gathering to eat isnt a profession, so the monkey prostitute is still the one with the profession.Da Orky Man said:Yeah, but since the male monkey needs to have bananas to trade, then the oldest profession is banana gatherer.Caiphus said:I don't understand. Why wouldn't it be prostitution?
Male monkey has bananas. Female monkey gets bananas for sex. Prehistoric prostitution.
Woefully inadequate explanations of ancient history now on sale. Get them quick.
This guy alluded to it.DVS BSTrD said:I think it would have to be hunter/gather and prostitution at the same time, since technically they could only become professions once the exchange of goods and services had been established. Before then they would have only been hobbies or survival activities.
But I also don't see any ice giants, regular giants, elves, orcs, goblins, halflings, lizardmen, snake people, werepeople, sasquatch, skyfish, gremlins.....oh my god....we killed them all.Ryan Minns said:Dragon slayers! They would have worked bloody hard also and a long time ago because nobody sees any dragons around do they?
Tax collectors don't get to keep the taxes they chase up. They are paid by a third party to perform their task. Hunter-gatherers were not paid by anyone to hunter-gather, they had to perform that task in order for survival. Prostitution is not needed for survival (in the animal kingdom it is considered prostitution when it happens outside of procreation and there is a service exchanged for it, shelter/protection/food).blackrave said:And what was the payment of such pre-historian prostitute?Stasisesque said:Profession means something you are paid for, hence prostitution being the world's oldest. In that regard, I don't doubt it. It's been observed in the animal kingdom that primates will trade sexual favours for food, shelter or protection. It's obvious in our society that that still happens, so I'd say it's at least possible both we and our primate cousins learned it from our ancestors.
I can't agree that hunter-gatherer was the oldest profession, as they typically hunter-gathered for themselves or their tribe, they weren't being paid to go out and get food. Food was the payment.
Food, mostly
So it is safe to assume that food could be considered as "money" (well one of, because barter)
So by same logic, if gathering money isn't considered job, then present day tax collectors and people responsible for emitting money aren't working either.
So I pretty much disagree on your opinion.
Job is something you do on regular basis that provides you with means to sustain your needs (not exact explanation, but I see job more along these lines)
So my vote goes for hunter or fisher.
P.S. OMG- so much "so"s. I really need to reread my posts more often![]()
Good points if it was first job it would be a different story but since it is profession that changes things. I think gatherer could still be the first however since it could be said that you are collecting food in exchange for expectance into the tribe which is a form of payment.Stasisesque said:Profession means something you are paid for, hence prostitution being the world's oldest. In that regard, I don't doubt it. It's been observed in the animal kingdom that primates will trade sexual favours for food, shelter or protection. It's obvious in our society that that still happens, so I'd say it's at least possible both we and our primate cousins learned it from our ancestors.
I can't agree that hunter-gatherer was the oldest profession, as they typically hunter-gathered for themselves or their tribe, they weren't being paid to go out and get food. Food was the payment.