irishda said:
Well, considering Magneto's power is the manipulation of all things metal, meaning he could crush Scott's skull with the visor (unless they made them out of plastic), or just send wolverine hurtling into him like his very own throwing knife, I don't know why Magneto would ever say Cyclops is his better/equal. You're right, Eric, the guy that can shoot lasers out of his eyes (but can't control it without blinding himself)is exactly as equal to you as the guy who can read and control people's fucking minds. Comics still have pretty shitty writers in the grand scheme of things, and unlike you and MovieBob, I'm never at all disappointed when they move away from comics.
As for Logan, People like Wolverine precisely because he's simple. He's an angry guy who stabs his problems away. He doesn't have to go through an arc. I agree that makes him a less interesting character, but it certainly makes him an entertaining one (see: Die Hard, God of War, Assassin's Creed protagonists, Thor "He learns humility by not bragging after he obliterates bad people!", Hulk [Not Bruce Banner, just Hulk], and really most video game protagonists).
yeah accept god of war was incredibly shitty writing after the first one. gow3 was so terrible because kratos was such a rage beast. look I like that aspect of logan, he's fun because he can dive into the middle of an army and fight his way out. but he's a hammer, and you can only get so much blood n guts before someone with a brain has to step in and direct that hammer somewhere otherwise it's pointless. logan is a cool character when used properly. old man logan is one of the best comics I've ever read. but it also illustrates that he's really only good at one thing, survival.
Cyclops power in the comics is a lot more than what they portray in the movies. at full power he can level magneto's force fields or just knock him around like a pinball. but Cyclops mutant power isn't what makes him so awesome. it's his tactics. kinda like cap, he's not the strongest avenger but he's possibly the most important because he has a plan and can implement it. Cyclops best attribute is harvesting the right tools and talent from the x-men and from the mutant population in general. magneto can "control" the mutant brotherhood. but Cyclops can "lead" the mutant rebellion. he's George Washington. the eye lazers are just a nice add. he's not holding back his powers because they might blind him. it's because if he doesn't hold them back he can burn holes in skyscrapers. they've explained the visor originally as needed due to brain damage that blocks his control but they've revealed that he's so careful to keep it under control that he has a mental block, a personality disorder, keeping him from controlling his powers. the few times he's gained complete control over his optic blasts he's defeated omega level mutants with ease. but the leadership thing, that's what magneto sees in him. magneto is working with Cyclops right now in the comics because he sees that Cyclops can actually succeed where he never could. Cyclops is the most important mutant because everything he does carries that banner of peaceful mutant/non mutant coexistence. and that's what the x-men are supposed to be about, showing people who hate and fear them that mutants are good and deserve to live. the fact that the movies more or less ignore the interactions between mutants and normal humans is laughable. it's always mutants fighting mutants. it's all about wolverine and the divide between magneto and prof x. both of which have been background characters in the comics for years. Xavier hasn't had anything to do with the x-men for something like 10 years. it's been Cyclops holding everything together this whole time.
sometimes moving away from comics is a good thing. the mandarin in iron man 3 was a GREAT thing. he was a silly character who needed the treatment he got. but if your just going to change stuff willy nilly for no good reason why bother adapting something. go make a die hard where jon mcclain is granted a healing factor and indestructible bones using unobtainium. but if your going to use the x-men, then use the fucking x-men. it's like making a movie out of halo and setting it in medieval England from the viewpoint of cortana. it kinda misses the point completely