I'm in a 3x3 thread and it's not on 4chan's /v/. This is a new experience for me. No inexplicable thread deletions!
From top left to bottom right: Kyousougiga, Isshuunkan Tomodachi, Sekai de Ichiban, Jormungand, Yuyushiki, Occult Academy, Maouyuusha, Kill La Kill and No Game No Life.
9 Honourable Mentions: Bakemonogatari. Katanagatari. SAO before the awful episode that ends the Aincrad arc... Alfhiem was just okay. Kotoura-san. Haganai. Gurren Lagann. Soranowoto. C3 Club. Seitokai Yakuindomo.
Edit: Oh, in before somebody says my runners up are better than my top 9.
From top left to bottom right: Kyousougiga, Isshuunkan Tomodachi, Sekai de Ichiban, Jormungand, Yuyushiki, Occult Academy, Maouyuusha, Kill La Kill and No Game No Life.
9 Honourable Mentions: Bakemonogatari. Katanagatari. SAO before the awful episode that ends the Aincrad arc... Alfhiem was just okay. Kotoura-san. Haganai. Gurren Lagann. Soranowoto. C3 Club. Seitokai Yakuindomo.
Edit: Oh, in before somebody says my runners up are better than my top 9.