Your (underrated) GotY 2012

[Entitled]

Crusader Kings 2 is probably the biggest niche hit this year, that is a genuine niche with a barrier that most people won't want to jump (as opposed to some "less-popular-than-COD-so-its-niche" games that everyone on gaming sites adores"), but it's also overwhelmingly popular in it's intended target audience.

A true cult classic in making.

 

[sextus the crazy]

Katawa Shoujo. Because the escapist and 4chan are the only places that know about the game.

How the flying fuck did I guess right on what game this was? Seriously, I read like 3 articles a year ago, didn't even know the title, and I was still right.

...

Does this mean I have to buy it now? Or at least torrent it?

Considering that torrenting is the only way to get the game (it's free), I'd recommend doing it. Also, because the game is a good experience to have, even if visual novels aren't your thing.

 

[hermes]

I will say "Mass Effect 3". The game was not perfect, but given all the overblown controversy about the ending it sure feels underrated.

 

[Sir Pootis]

I'll have to go with Spec Ops for this one.