Reed Spacer said:
So I guess you could say it didn't have a Ghost of a chance?
This is the best post in the thread and it will likely never be topped.
I think CoD is in a sort of uncanny valley period where the narrative still has yet to catch up to the universe. Most of the people who take a moral high ground over the series had no issues mercilessly slaughtering Russians in the old arcade side-scrollers of the '80s because there just wasn't much context to tie it into real-world logic: the worlds portrayed were cartoonish and ridiculous and the story was non-existent. Compare that to today's military first person shooters that attempt to shoehorn in graphic realism and vast political plots, yet still take the same care-free attitude of the "vaguely nationally themed and that's it" military side-scrolling shooters that preceeded them. Suddenly "shoot the person of a different color" takes on several new meanings.
Simply put, these developers are trying to apply old design philosophies into new environments where they're not nearly as compatible or as plausible.