Ehh, I like anime and I like a good romance and I've kind of been thinking about giving dating sims a go but if, as Yahtz says, the romantic options are shallow-ass walking wish fulfillment that exists only to date the MC with no agency of their own, that kind of dulls my interest considerably. Can anyone confirm if the genre really suffers from that sort of thing? I've got Hatoful Boyfriend in my backlog, I'll probably at least give it a go sometime anyway, but does that conform to this stereotype?
In other news, like many others I'm surprised Yahtzee let himself be pressured into anything. TBH, I don't actually think dating sim was the most entertaining possible genre. Myself, I'd LOVE seeing him play Dwarf Fortress or something strongly DF-inspired like Rimworld. The freedom in these titles allows an efficiency-minded player to perform some very entertaining - and sensible - atrocities, like the "dwarven nursery" idea, where children are subjected to full-body third degree burns and then forced into an extended pit fight with a gaggle of stressed-out puppies until maturity, to develop their combat stats. I suspect he'd love the concept, but all the same he doesn't like learning extensive game mechanics, so I expect he'd end up with a game he wants to love, but can't really play and gets pissed off at all the same, which would be hilarious to watch. Still, nice to see the guy step out of his comfort zone, good on him.