Hey all, I've been watching Zero Punctuation for quite a while, and decided to make an account today to chime in about this game. Please ignore my appropriately pun-y name.
First though, a few points:
1) A trilby is a type of fedora. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trilby
-Also he didn't have the hat when she married him (Ronin), she gave it to him after watching some gangster movie. Then he "never took it off".
2) This game is on current/last gen consoles, I own it on 360.
Ok, to business, I bought this a day or two after release completely on impulse. I had never seen or heard of it before, just saw pretty pictures and got it. I should also say I don't buy much for consoles anymore, and very little about them excites me either.
I think the downside to this game lies in it's simplicity. It feels like there's something missing, there are collectibles which unlock some interesting little ghost stories, which are read to you like your around a campfire (I really liked these). Apart from this there are files strewn about with background on most main characters, which were nice too, but with a lot of freedom to explore I wish there was more to find. As for "combat", well it wasn't ideal, but I kept thinking I was going to get some kind of "ghost gun" toward the end. I was greatly pleased that I didn't, for what it's worth, they don't change anything in that regard. Your first encounter will likely go the same as your last, except you'll have a few powers to help out.
On the plus side, I think the story and characters were pretty well done, Ronin doesn't feel like a typical protagonist. He actually seems street-wise and pragmatic, rather than being led by supporting characters. I also thought the flashback intro worked well, can't stand intros like, "Hey! Ronin, my brother-in-law! Man, you sure love my sister, since you married her and now are a police detective, despite your troubled past! Too bad she died, huh?" It lets you see who he is and what his life was like, and seems to make sense in that he's about to die and his life flashes before his eyes. (didn't need to copy the scene from Matrix though)
What I liked most though were the remnants of the spirit world, mostly the creepy images of people hanging around (sometimes literally) that disappear when you get too close. The first instance of this is an old couple's apartment, in which the tub seems to be haunted by some kind of bound woman or something. This and the random ghosts you'll run into, some of which have no bearing on you or the game, it's just a distraction. These helped to fill the gaps, yet it still feels unfinished.
I would recommend it to anyone curious, but I do have to agree a $30 price would be easier to swallow. Sorry for a huge first post, thanks if anyone actually read it. And just to establish myself as an anti-hipster, never looked into Dresden Files.