Watched a pair of Anime series from the same genre, roughly the same time and covering some overlapping themes. First of which is
Ergo Proxy
Mid 00's dystopian science-fiction, starting off in what's one of the very few, possibly the last, large cities that maintain some degree of civilized life and advanced technology in what's otherwise a post apocalyptic wasteland. EP is, mainly, the story of the cities security chief Re-L Mayer, an emotionally guarded young woman with some impressive mall goth fashion, and meek immigrant Vincent Law pursuing the mysteries of a strange monstrous creature called Proxy running wild in the city and it's android workforce developing sentience and going rogue.
Despite its use of some stock Cyberpunk ideas, Ergo Proxy is nothing if not eager to throw in everything but the kitchen sink when it comes to fleshing out that plot. Ergo Proxy is a grab bag of narrative and stylistic digressions that are irritating as often as they're compelling. Where it starts off relatively tightly in setting up its main premise and characters, once it settles into the journey across the wasteland that makes for its second act it starts to get carried away quite badly.
I'm not saying that Ergo Proxy tries too hard, tempting as it is. But I will say that Ergo Proxy tries too much. Straight up, the reason that I'm not the biggest anime fan is that I always felt that 20 minutes are too short a time frame for any serious episodic storytelling, which is why most of my actual favourites tend to have more of a long form approach. Ergo Proxy has plenty of odd one off episodes (among them some borderline non sequiturs like a quiz show and one set in a Disney World parody inhabited by cartoon characters) utilizing ideas that a 40 - 60 minutes episode might have explored enough to turn into worthwhile side stories, but as self contained 20 minutes episodes, never really manage to grow into more than gimmicks
It doesn't help that even once the main plot comes back into focus, the writers couldn't help getting carried away. The series has, quite consistently, a good amount of heavy handed philosophical discussions, that occasionally veer dangerously close to the insufferable name dropping of surface level pop philosophy that made me strongly dislike Taro's Nier Automata. What is a mildly brow raising quirk for most of the show escalates to the point of absurdity towards the end.
Ergo Proxy does quite a good job being a hard boiled dystopian action thriller when it actually wants to be, but in the end, just when it seems like its ready to put its experiments of varying success behind itself, it unravels into some of the silliest and most over the top operatic JRPG cheese that a series like this could possibly end on.
There is some likeability to Ergo Proxy's weird patchwork of valid, if sometimes cliché Cyberpunk tropes, airheaded new age prog rock operatics and left field non sequiturs inbetween but that charm isn't really enough to push it into genuinely good territory. Much moreso, Ergo Proxy feels like the work of a talented amateur, it's something that shows great promise in many different places, a lot of its art design is absolutely on point, but the writing betrays a lack of focus and restraint. Too many digressions, too many gimmicks, too much dialogue spelling out what should only be alluded to, too much semi spiritual pretension. I'm a shameless maximalist most of the time, but in case of Ergo Proxy, a bit less would have probably been more.
A much more succesful example of a dystopian anime series is Texhnolyze, which I'll write about later.